The critically praised limited series Say Nothing has arrived on Channel 4, offering UK viewers a powerful and unforgettable drama to delve into this festive season. Originally debuting on Disney+, this FX production, adapted from Patrick Radden Keefe's bestselling book, has been hailed as a television masterpiece and a standout show of the year.
A Harrowing Story of Silence and Violence
Set during the early years of the Northern Ireland Troubles, the series chillingly explores a culture of suffocating silence. It centres on the kidnapping of Jean McConville, a mother-of-ten and suspected informant, who is dragged from her home in one of the opening scenes. This event sets the tone for a profoundly disturbing yet completely captivating nine-episode journey.
The narrative follows former IRA operatives Marian and Dolours Price, portrayed with brilliance by Hazel Doupe and Lola Petticrew respectively. Petticrew, who also starred in the Channel 4 drama Trespasses, delivers a compelling performance. The series also features Anthony Boyle, known for House of Guinness, as Brendan Hughes, and a convincing Josh Finan as a young Gerry Adams.
Critical Acclaim and Controversial Perspectives
With a 94% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, Say Nothing has garnered significant praise. The Sunday Times, on December 7, described it as "beautifully nuanced and scripted," commending its avoidance of romanticising its central figures. However, the drama has also sparked debate.
In the Irish Independent, Elis O'Hanlon offered a contrasting view, suggesting the series extends misplaced compassion to "morally dubious" characters and makes viewers "accomplices to their self-vindication." This division reflects the complex legacy the series examines. Furthermore, the show is entangled in real-world controversy, as republican Marian 'Price' McGlinchey is pursuing legal action against Walt Disney and a production firm for its portrayal of Jean McConville's death.
An Emotionally Charged Must-Watch
Beyond its political narrative, Say Nothing is a masterclass in suspenseful, emotional storytelling. It delivers harrowing scenes of overwhelming sorrow, punctuated by brilliant wit and edge-of-your-seat tension. A disclaimer at the end of each episode notes that Gerry Adams denies "participating in any IRA-related violence."
Regardless of one's political stance or final judgement on the characters, the series is universally captivating. It stands as a deeply affecting, courageous, and audacious piece of television. For anyone seeking substantive, thought-provoking drama over the holidays, Say Nothing on Channel 4 is an essential watch and a strong contender for the most impactful show of the year.
