Manchester United's summer transfer activity has come under the microscope after a challenging start to the season, with several big-money signings struggling to justify their price tags at Old Trafford.
The Hit and Miss Summer Spending Spree
Erik ten Hag embarked on a significant rebuilding mission during the 2023 transfer window, but the results have been decidedly mixed. From expensive flops to promising talents, the Red Devils' business is being graded as the season approaches its climax.
Mason Mount: The £60 Million Question Mark
Perhaps the most scrutinised acquisition has been Mason Mount, who arrived from Chelsea for an initial £55 million potentially rising to £60 million. The England international has failed to make the anticipated impact, managing just one assist in 15 appearances amid persistent injury concerns.
Verdict: D- - A signing that currently looks like poor business given the substantial investment and minimal return.
Andre Onana: From Nightmare Start to Steady Improvement
Cameroonian goalkeeper Andre Onana endured a torrid beginning to his United career, making several high-profile errors in Champions League matches. However, the £47 million signing from Inter Milan has shown recent improvement, suggesting there might be better to come.
Verdict: C - Showing signs of recovery after a concerning start between the posts.
Rasmus Hojlund: Raw Talent with Promise
The young Danish striker arrived with enormous expectations following his £72 million move from Atalanta. While Hojlund took time to find his feet in the Premier League, his five goals in six Champions League appearances demonstrated his potential.
Verdict: B - Clear talent evident despite needing time to adapt to English football's demands.
The Loan Market and Bargain Business
United's activity wasn't limited to blockbuster signings, with several strategic moves designed to bolster the squad depth.
Sofyan Amrabat: Midfield Reinforcements
The Moroccan international arrived on loan from Fiorentina with an option to make the move permanent for £21.4 million. While showing flashes of quality, consistency has been elusive.
Verdict: C+ - A useful squad addition but perhaps not the transformative midfield presence needed.
Jonny Evans: The Surprise Return
In what many considered a nostalgic move, Jonny Evans returned to United on a free transfer after leaving Leicester City. The Northern Irish defender has proven to be a surprisingly reliable option when called upon.
Verdict: B - Exceeded expectations as a cost-effective defensive cover.
Looking Ahead: The Ruben Amorim Connection
As pressure mounts on Erik ten Hag, Sporting Lisbon manager Ruben Amorim has emerged as a potential successor. The highly-rated Portuguese coach represents a modern, progressive option should United decide to make a change.
With the summer transfer window already looming, United's recruitment team faces increased pressure to deliver more consistent success in the market, learning from both the hits and misses of their recent business.
