Manchester United found themselves at the centre of a Premier League first during their recent match against Crystal Palace, becoming the initial team affected by a significant penalty rule change that ultimately cost them a goal.
The Controversial Selhurst Park Incident
The dramatic moment unfolded at Selhurst Park on Sunday when Crystal Palace striker Jean-Philippe Mateta stepped up to take a penalty after being fouled by United defender Leny Yoro during the first half. As Mateta approached the ball, he slipped during his kicking motion, accidentally making contact with the ball twice as it struck his standing foot before finding its way into the net.
While the ball initially ended up in the goal, the VAR officials immediately identified the infringement, known as a double touch. Under previous football regulations, this would have resulted in the goal being disallowed and an indirect free-kick awarded to Manchester United.
The New Rule Explained
However, a recent update to the laws of the game introduced a different outcome for such scenarios. The revised rule now permits a penalty retake in specific circumstances, particularly when the double contact is deemed accidental and the ball still enters the goal.
Referee Rob Jones explained the technical decision to the confused crowd at Selhurst Park, ordering the spot-kick to be taken again. Mateta was given a second opportunity from twelve yards and successfully converted his retaken penalty into the opposite corner, giving Crystal Palace the lead in the match despite the initial controversy.
Historical Context and Precedents
This Premier League landmark wasn't without precedent in other competitions. The rule change was prompted by a similar chaotic incident involving Julian Alvarez during a Champions League shootout between Atletico Madrid and Real Madrid. This prompted UEFA and the International Football Association Board to update the laws to handle accidental double touches more fairly.
While this marked a Premier League first, the rule has already been witnessed in other major tournaments. England star Beth Mead was allowed a similar retake during the Euro 2025 final shootout against Spain, demonstrating the rule's growing implementation across the football world.
The implementation of this new regulation ensured Palace weren't penalised for an accidental slip, allowing them to maintain their attacking advantage. United, however, found themselves on the unfortunate receiving end of this historic refereeing decision that continues to shape modern football.
