In a stunning defiance of critical consensus, the television series All's Fair, which has been lambasted as the 'worst show of all time', appears to be on the cusp of a second season renewal. Despite holding a dismal 4% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the show's impressive viewer numbers have reportedly convinced streaming giant Hulu to move forward.
The Power of Audience Numbers
According to an insider speaking to The U.S. Sun, the data for All's Fair has been nothing short of phenomenal. The ratings have been incredible, with the source revealing it has become the biggest Hulu premiere drop in years and one of the biggest of all time.
The insider elaborated, stating, "There was an enormous shift within the first 24 hours and the momentum hasn't stopped there." This overwhelming response has led Hulu to inform the show's creator, Ryan Murphy, that they are "all in for a season two", with Murphy already penning the new scripts.
A Star-Studded Cast Embraces the 'Joke'
The show, which features a glittering ensemble cast including Kim Kardashian, Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, and Niecy Nash, seems to have been a positive experience for those involved. The source confirmed that the entire cast is expected to be invited back, noting, "They all love each other and loved the experience. They're in on the joke, they would happily return."
This behind-the-scenes camaraderie contrasts sharply with the public reception from professional critics, who have universally panned the series. However, a very different conversation is happening among viewers on social media.
So Bad, It's Good: The Audience Verdict
While critics have been brutal, a dedicated fanbase has emerged on platforms like X (formerly Twitter), where viewers are celebrating the show's unique appeal. Many are labelling it as "camp" and finding entertainment in its perceived flaws.
One user defended the show, writing, "Critics don't know how to have fun anymore! #AllsFair is for the fashion and the camp!" Another fan praised its paradoxical quality, stating, "All's Fair on Hulu dares to ask the question 'Does a show need to be good?' and the answer is no, it doesn't."
Further comments highlight this 'so bad it's good' phenomenon, with one viewer noting the "horrible script" and "horrible acting", yet admitting the show is "so fun" to watch. The extravagant fashion and the collective effort of the legendary cast seem to be key drivers of its unexpected popularity.
For viewers in the UK, All's Fair is available to stream now on Disney+, allowing audiences to decide for themselves if this critically-mauled but audience-adored series is a television crime or a guilty pleasure.
