Netflix reality series Members Only: Palm Beach may be heading for a second season, but drama is already brewing between two of its closest stars. Gale Brophy and Rosalyn Yellin, who were once close friends, reportedly had a heated argument at a friend's birthday party over the weekend, leaving one of them on the floor.
Party Row Details
According to reports, the incident occurred on a small boat during a celebration for Leesa Rowland. An insider told Page Six that Gale ended up on the ground for about 15 minutes, claiming that Rosalyn pushed her. The source said: “Gale was on the ground for like 15 minutes. She said Rosalyn pushed her. It caused such a scene and ruined Leesa’s party.”
Rosalyn confirmed the argument but insisted nothing physical happened. She stated: “She was drinking a lot of Prosecco, and the pontoon’s tiki bar was rocking, as it normally would, and she fell, and said I pushed her with my butt, and I said, ‘I didn’t push you’. She probably shouldn’t have been up and dancing – moving and rocking – at her age, if she couldn’t handle the rocking boat.”
Gale's Side of the Story
Gale reportedly apologised to her friend and the group via text before sharing her version of events. She confirmed she had been “drinking since the morning” but was not pushed by anyone. She added: “I have a fake hip, and I was worried since I was jostled, and I landed right on the fake hip. They all wanted me to go, but I didn’t because I can see I was fine.”
About Members Only: Palm Beach
The reality show debuted on Netflix last December, following a tight-knit group of friends navigating an affluent Florida community filled with champagne, brunches, and blazing rows. The cast also includes Hilary Musser, Taja Abitbol, Ro-mina Ustayev, and Maria Cozamanis. While a second season has not been confirmed, tensions among the cast are clearly high.
However, not all locals were pleased with the series. Palm Beach publicist Marianna Abbate told the Hollywood Reporter: “Palm Beach is about quiet luxury. People here don’t seek attention.”
