Manchester United's dramatic victory over Wolves has been completely overshadowed by a furious VAR controversy that has left the football world demanding answers about Premier League officiating standards.
The match, which ended 1-0 to United thanks to Raphael Varane's second-half header, will be remembered not for the goal but for the astonishing penalty decision that wasn't given in the final moments of stoppage time.
The Incident That Shook Molineux
In the 96th minute, with Wolves pushing desperately for an equaliser, United goalkeeper André Onana came charging out for a high ball. The Cameroonian international collided violently with Wolves' Sasa Kalajdzic, sending the striker tumbling to the ground in what appeared to be a clear penalty incident.
Remarkably, referee Simon Hooper waved play on, and despite a lengthy VAR check from Michael Salisbury at Stockley Park, the decision stood. The fallout was immediate and explosive.
Wolves' Fury and Official Complaint
Wolves have officially submitted a formal complaint to the Premier League, expressing their "anger and frustration" at what they describe as a "clear and obvious error." Manager Gary O'Neil revealed he received an apology from referees' chief Jon Moss, who admitted the officials had got it wrong.
"To get an apology after is something I certainly don't want," fumed O'Neil. "We should have had a penalty and the chance to take a point from the game. The apology doesn't help me or my players."
Expert Pundits Unanimous in Criticism
The incident has drawn condemnation from across the football community. Premier League legend Gary Neville called the decision "scandalous" during commentary, while fellow pundit Jamie Carragher simply stated: "That's a penalty. No doubt about it."
Former referee Mike Dean admitted on Sky Sports that he "would have given it" if still officiating, adding that the VAR team likely didn't want to overturn a subjective call from their colleague.
Broader Implications for Premier League
This controversy comes at a sensitive time for Premier League officiating, with PGMOL already under pressure to improve consistency and transparency in VAR decisions. The failure to award what appeared to be a clear penalty has raised serious questions about the application of the "clear and obvious error" standard.
With the new season just one matchday old, this incident has already set a concerning precedent that will undoubtedly fuel the ongoing debate about the effectiveness of VAR in English football.
