Secret Messages Expose Labour's Internal Tensions and Strategy Woes
Health Secretary Wes Streeting has voluntarily published a series of private messages exchanged with the disgraced former minister Lord Mandelson, revealing deep concerns about Labour's strategic direction under Prime Minister Keir Starmer. The correspondence, which spans from August 2024 to October 2025, was released as Streeting sought to distance himself from the ongoing scandal surrounding Number 10.
Criticism of Government Strategy and Personal Career Fears
In the messages, Streeting openly criticised the Government's approach, lamenting the absence of a clear economic philosophy and coherent policy programme. He specifically highlighted the lack of a growth strategy, stating emphatically, 'No growth strategy at all.' This critique underscores broader anxieties within Labour about its ideological footing and practical governance.
Adding to the tension, Streeting expressed significant personal doubts about his political future. Following a council by-election in March 2025 where Labour lost its safest ward in Ilford South to a 'Gaza independent' candidate, he confided in Mandelson, 'I fear we're in big trouble here – and I am toast at the next election.' With a wafer-thin majority of just 528 in his Ilford North constituency, these fears reflect the precarious position of many Labour MPs amid shifting voter sentiments.
Palestine Recognition and Foreign Policy Concerns
The messages also delve into foreign policy, with Streeting seeking Mandelson's advice on the recognition of Palestine. He described Israel's actions as 'committing war crimes before our eyes' and engaging in 'rogue state behaviour.' Streeting argued that Labour should be 'leading the charge on this,' advocating for sanctions against the state rather than just individual ministers.
In response, Lord Mandelson cautioned that recognising Palestine could potentially undermine a two-state solution, a concern that highlights the complex diplomatic calculations involved. Despite this, the Government proceeded with recognition in September of last year, a move that Streeting supported, noting he and now-Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood could not abstain or vote against it in any Commons vote.
Attempts to Distance from Mandelson and Broader Implications
In the wake of the scandal, Streeting has attempted to downplay his relationship with Mandelson, describing him as not a close friend and stating they met 'for dinner on average once a year, in a group setting.' He emphasised that Mandelson merely 'offered advice,' including connections to US politicians like Pete Buttigieg and guidance ahead of a meeting with US health secretary Robert Kennedy Jr.
However, the association has raised eyebrows in Westminster, with some viewing it as a potential obstacle should Streeting seek to succeed Starmer as Labour leader. The messages conclude with Streeting ceasing communication after Mandelson was sacked, though the peer continued to share updates without reply.
Calls for Change and Reflection on the Scandal
Reflecting on the broader scandal, Streeting has called for 'real change' in political appointments, criticising the decision to appoint Mandelson as ambassador despite his association with Jeffrey Epstein. He argued that this 'did not weigh heavily enough with decision-makers,' suggesting that having figures like Home Office minister Jess Phillips in the room might have prevented the appointment.
Despite his earlier pessimism, Streeting has since expressed optimism about the economy, citing growth and falling interest rates, and reaffirmed his commitment to stand in Ilford North, where he now sees increased support from previously non-Labour voters.
