Labour's Shadow Foreign Secretary David Lammy has launched a blistering attack on the Conservative government, accusing them of an "unprecedented power grab" over the appointment of senior judges.
In a speech delivered to The Law Society, the senior MP warned that proposed changes to the judicial appointments process would allow the government to "pack the courts" with politically sympathetic judges.
Constitutional Principles Under Threat
Lammy argued that the government's plans represent a fundamental threat to the separation of powers, a cornerstone of Britain's constitutional arrangement. "The idea that the executive should have a direct say in who sits as a senior judge is deeply alarming," he stated.
The current system involves independent selection commissions that recommend candidates based on merit, with the Lord Chancellor typically accepting their recommendations.
Historical Context and Warnings
Drawing parallels with constitutional crises throughout British history, Lammy reminded attendees that judicial independence has been hard-won over centuries. "From the struggles against absolute monarchy to the establishment of an independent judiciary, Britain has fought to keep political influence out of the courts," he said.
The MP warned that the proposed changes could undermine public confidence in the justice system and damage Britain's international reputation for legal fairness.
Government's Defence
While the government has argued that reforms are necessary to ensure accountability, Lammy dismissed this as a "thinly veiled excuse" for expanding executive power. He questioned why, after centuries of successful judicial independence, such radical changes were suddenly necessary.
The speech comes amid growing tension between the judiciary and the executive, particularly following several high-profile cases where courts have ruled against government actions.
What Happens Next?
Legal experts and constitutional scholars have expressed concern that the proposed changes could face significant opposition in the House of Lords and from the legal profession itself.
Lammy concluded with a rallying cry to defend Britain's constitutional settlement, urging all parties to "stand up for the independence of our judiciary" against what he termed "this dangerous power grab."
