The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) is facing mounting criticism after choosing to keep its crucial climate adaptation plan hidden from public view, sparking outrage among environmental organisations and transparency advocates.
In a move described as "deeply concerning" by campaigners, the government has confirmed it will not publish the third National Adaptation Programme (NAP3) for public consultation, breaking from established precedent and raising questions about its commitment to addressing the climate emergency.
What is the National Adaptation Programme?
The National Adaptation Programme represents the UK's strategic blueprint for preparing the nation against the escalating impacts of climate change. This comprehensive plan addresses critical issues including flooding, extreme heat, drought, and other climate-related threats that increasingly affect communities across Britain.
Previous iterations of the programme underwent public consultation, allowing experts, organisations, and citizens to contribute valuable insights before finalisation. This transparent approach has now been abandoned without explanation.
Environmental Groups Voice Outrage
Leading environmental organisations have expressed profound disappointment with Defra's decision. The Wildlife Trusts' climate change policy manager, Kathryn Brown, emphasised the critical nature of public engagement, stating that proper consultation ensures the plan's effectiveness and robustness.
"The decision not to consult on such an important plan is deeply concerning," Brown stated. "Proper consultation isn't just a bureaucratic hurdle – it ensures the plan is fit for purpose and properly addresses the climate challenges we face."
Government's Defensive Stance
Defra has defended its position, claiming the plan will be laid before Parliament "in due course" and insisting it will build upon progress made through previous adaptation programmes. A government spokesperson highlighted existing initiatives, including investment in flood protection and nature restoration.
However, environmental advocates remain sceptical, pointing to the Climate Change Committee's recent assessment that found "very limited evidence" of the UK adapting adequately to climate risks. The committee specifically noted insufficient action in managing overheating risks in homes, safeguarding natural habitats, and addressing impacts on farming and fisheries.
Broader Implications for Climate Policy
This development comes amid growing scrutiny of the government's environmental commitments. With climate impacts becoming increasingly severe and visible – from devastating floods to record-breaking heatwaves – the need for a comprehensive, publicly-vetted adaptation strategy has never been more urgent.
The decision to forgo consultation raises significant questions about the government's approach to climate governance and its willingness to incorporate diverse perspectives in tackling one of the greatest challenges of our time.
