The new reality competition show The Summit has been criticised as staged and fake, with viewers and critics questioning the authenticity of the challenges and the contestants' reactions. The show, which airs on Channel 4, features 14 strangers attempting to climb a mountain in the New Zealand Alps despite having little to no climbing experience.
Critics have pointed out that many contestants appear to be selected for their lack of suitability, with one reviewer noting that 'none of them, naturally, has ever climbed a mountain before' and that 'it's possible that some have never seen a mountain before'. The show has been accused of manufacturing drama, including a 'Mountain Keeper' helicopter that drops instructions mid-challenge.
Viewers have also taken issue with the casting, which includes Afton, daughter of former I'm a Celebrity contestant Gillian McKeith, and Warren, a former Gladiators star turned Anglican minister. The show's host, Ben Shephard, has been described as 'barely' present, appearing only briefly at the start of each episode.
Despite the backlash, Channel 4 has defended the show, stating that all challenges are real and that contestants are genuinely tested. However, the negative reception has led to speculation that the show may not be renewed for a second season.
