Netflix's House Of Guinness Faces Irish Backlash
Netflix's House Of Guinness Faces Irish Backlash

Netflix's new series House of Guinness, which debuted to strong ratings and positive reviews from US and UK critics, has been met with a barrage of criticism in Ireland. The show, described as a cross between Succession and Peaky Blinders, has been praised by outlets such as The Guardian and the BBC, but Irish reviewers have condemned its depiction of history, dialogue, costumes, and lighting.

The Irish Times criticised the show's 'rudimentary understanding of Ireland's experiences of colonialism' and its 'stunning lack of appreciation for who the Anglo-Irish were'. It described the lead character, played by English actor James Norton, as sounding like 'a steampunk Mr Tayto' – a reference to an Irish crisp brand mascot – and said the Fenian revolutionaries 'dress and speak like feral leprechauns'.

The Irish Independent called the show a 'shocker' that frittered away authenticity, noting that 'cliches arrive thick and fast' and that characters swear too much. The review added that while the producers state the series is fiction, 'the majority of our popular history is fiction, and quite dangerous fiction at that'.

Social media users also voiced displeasure, with one Reddit contributor questioning the costume design: 'Green doesn't equal Irish. Why are all the Fenians wearing literal spirit Halloween leprechaun costumes?' Comedian Garron Noone, who has over 2 million followers on TikTok and Instagram, noted that the first episode features a character shouting 'Free Ireland from the English!' within the first four minutes.

Irish critics also cited clunky dialogue, dim lighting, and a lack of the comedy and jeopardy promised by its Succession and Peaky Blinders comparisons. The Irish Examiner headlined its review 'all pour, no pint'. Despite the backlash, the show holds an 89% audience approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and has been praised for its soundtrack and big-budget sets.