BBC's Gentleman Jack Declared a Masterpiece Surpassing Downton Abbey
A little-known period drama available on BBC iPlayer has been receiving extraordinary acclaim from both critics and viewers, with many describing it as a superior alternative to the beloved Downton Abbey. This hidden gem, which offers a refreshing and original take on historical storytelling, is being celebrated as one of the most compelling series currently available on television.
A Sensual and Playful Historical Drama
Gentleman Jack, the British historical drama created by acclaimed writer Sally Wainwright of Happy Valley fame, has been characterized as "sensual," "playful," and "brilliant" by those who have discovered it. While frequently compared to Downton Abbey for its period setting and ensemble cast, this series distinguishes itself with considerably more intensity and emotional depth. Remarkably, the narrative is grounded in the true story of a real historical figure, adding authenticity to its compelling plotlines.
The series represents a collaborative production between BBC One and HBO, making its UK television debut in 2019 with a second season following in 2022. Although HBO confirmed they would not commission a third series, the BBC has expressed interest in continuing the story, contingent upon securing new production partners to bring additional seasons to life.
Exceptional Cast and Compelling Narrative
Headlined by the remarkable Suranne Jones alongside the gifted Sophie Rundle, Gentleman Jack features performances that have earned widespread critical acclaim. Jones, in particular, has been praised for her nuanced portrayal of the central character. The exceptional ensemble cast is further strengthened by supporting performances from Joe Armstrong, Amelia Bullmore, Rosie Cavaliero, Gemma Jones, Gemma Whelan, and Timothy West, creating a rich tapestry of characters that bring 1830s West Yorkshire to vivid life.
The series transports viewers to 1832 West Yorkshire during the Industrial Revolution, where landowner Anne Lister is determined to save her ancestral home, Shibden Hall, despite societal expectations. Lister's unconventional approach includes reopening coal mines and pursuing a marriage strategy that defies contemporary norms. The charismatic, single-minded protagonist, who dresses entirely in black and navigates high society with charm, has no intention of marrying a man. Instead, the drama explores Lister's complex relationships with family, servants, tenants, industrial rivals, and potential romantic partners.
What makes Gentleman Jack particularly compelling is its foundation in historical reality. The real Anne Lister documented her life in extensive diaries, and the series draws upon these intimate records to reveal authentic details about her experiences and relationships.
Critical Acclaim and Audience Adoration
With an impressive 92% average rating across both seasons on Rotten Tomatoes, Gentleman Jack has attracted widespread critical praise. One reviewer described it as "an utter gem of British drama" that is "lively, tongue-in-cheek at times and enormously playful." Another critic celebrated the program as "exuberant, fun, and playful" while noting its ability to uplift viewers. A third assessment labeled it "a buoyant, utterly seductive drama" that captivates from beginning to end.
Perhaps most significantly, some critics have declared Gentleman Jack a "masterpiece" that disrupts conventions within the period drama genre at a time when such innovation is most needed. One review emphasized that the series remains "one of the most original and refreshing series on television," praising Suranne Jones for balancing her character's strength and vulnerability with remarkable skill. Another critic characterized the program as "a rare and genuine treat" that combines authentic period detail with fully relatable emotional depth.
Enthusiastic Viewer Response
Audience reviews for Gentleman Jack mirror the critical acclaim, with viewers expressing extraordinary enthusiasm for the series. On IMDB, one user declared they were "enjoying every minute of this outstanding series" and awarded it their highest rating, describing it as "highly worth your time." Another enthusiastic fan expressed profound admiration for Suranne Jones's portrayal of Anne Lister, noting how the performance captures both masculine and feminine qualities with captivating authenticity.
Rotten Tomatoes audience reviews further reinforce the series' popularity, with one viewer noting they re-watched the entire first season before beginning the second and "thoroughly re-enjoyed it." This reviewer praised Jones's performance as "intoxicating" and celebrated the perfect casting of every role, along with exceptional production values that rival any period drama they've encountered. Additional viewer comments have described Gentleman Jack as "the best show that ever is or was" and simply declared "Best show. Period. Better does simply not exist."
One particularly glowing audience review summarized the series as "an absolute delight" that offers "a fascinating look into history through the true diaries of a woman who dared to live as she desired." This viewer appreciated how the program combines drama, love, humor, beauty, and historical authenticity, while expressing disappointment about HBO's cancellation of a potential third season.
Both complete seasons of Gentleman Jack are currently available to stream for free on BBC iPlayer, offering audiences the opportunity to discover this critically acclaimed period drama that has been hailed as superior to Downton Abbey in its storytelling, performances, and emotional impact.
