The Royal Australian Mint has found itself at the centre of a heated debate following the release of two commemorative coins depicting the late Queen Elizabeth II. The limited-edition silver coins, created to mark the centenary of the Queen's birth, have drawn significant criticism online, with many claiming the portrait bears little resemblance to the beloved monarch and even suggesting it makes her look as though she has "run into a wall."
Public Reaction to the Coin Design
Images of the $5 and 50-cent coins were shared on social media ahead of a public ballot, prompting a flurry of negative reactions. One critic described it as "the most unpleasant portrait on a coin," while another remarked, "There's a reason most portraits are from the side. Looks like she just ran into a wall." A third commenter added, "If I saw that face without the hairdo and pearls, would never guess who it was meant to be." Some went further, comparing the depiction to fictional characters like Mrs Doubtfire, played by the late Robin Williams.
Defence from the Mint and Supportive Voices
In response to the backlash, the Royal Australian Mint defended the artwork, stating, "Our coin images don't always capture the full beauty of a design once it's etched in metal." The portrait was created by one of the mint's own artists. Despite the criticism, not all feedback was negative. Supporters praised the tribute, with one writing, "Awesome. I'm glad they put something out to do with Queen Elizabeth II, she deserves to have Recognition In a Special Way." Another enthusiast pleaded, "Please pick me for one of these coins," and a woman in the US called it "a beautiful coin."
Details of the Coin Release and Sales
The commemorative coins were produced in limited quantities, with 30,000 of the 50-cent coins and 5,000 of the $5 coins available. According to Australian media, the silver proof coins sold out rapidly, with only limited stock remaining in the mint's contact centre and shop. Collectors reported that the ballot was fully subscribed, indicating strong demand despite the design controversy. Importantly, these are collector's items and will not enter general circulation.
Symbolic Elements and Additional Features
The coins feature more than just the Queen's portrait. The design includes symbolic motifs reflecting various aspects of Queen Elizabeth II's life and legacy. These incorporate a horse and a corgi, references to art and theatre highlighting her enduring support for culture, and depictions of her favourite flowers, such as roses and lily of the valley. The golden wattle, Australia's national floral emblem, is also represented. Additionally, the mint noted that the design incorporates Her Majesty's Royal Cypher, a stylised St Edward's Crown, and the Auxiliary Territorial Service emblem, acknowledging her wartime service and lifelong sense of duty. The reverse side of the coins features a profile portrait of King Charles.
Queen Elizabeth II, who passed away in 2022 at the age of 96, was the United Kingdom's longest-serving monarch. This release aims to honour her memory, but the mixed reactions underscore the challenges in capturing a widely recognised figure on such a small canvas. The debate continues as collectors and critics alike weigh in on the artistic interpretation of a historic icon.
