BBC Look North presenter Amanda Harper has issued a powerful rebuke to online trolls who viciously criticized her choice of leather trousers, declaring in a defiant social media video that she will continue wearing the controversial garment. The 52-year-old broadcaster faced a barrage of cruel comments after sharing images of her outfit on Instagram back in February, with detractors labeling her appearance "unflattering" and "far too tight."
Standing Firm Against Criticism
Amanda Harper showcased her resilience by posting a new video where she confidently models the same leather trousers that sparked the initial controversy. The presenter directly addressed her critics with the firm declaration: "they're staying." She shared some of the most hurtful comments received, including comparisons to "mutton dressed as lamb" and descriptions of her look as "terrible" and "horrid."
Despite the negativity, Harper emphasized that supportive voices significantly outnumbered the critical ones. She wrote: "I'm delighted that lovely people outnumber the not so lovely. Thank you for the reminder. The trousers live on. In fact I might even wear them more often." In her Instagram reel, she added: "This video sparked a wave of nasty comments... But most people were kind. The trousers stay."
Overwhelming Support from Followers
The broadcaster's defiant stance triggered an outpouring of encouragement from her social media followers. Supporters flooded the comments section with messages praising her confidence and style. One admirer wrote: "Definitely wear them often. You look fabulous," while another commented: "You look incredible, and you dress to please yourself." A third supporter added: "Keep wearing-it really hacks off the haters."
Additional messages highlighted Harper's consistent elegance, with one follower noting: "Every single time my mum and I see you on Look North, we say how lovely you always look, we love your outfits and style!" Another observer pointed out: "You look great and confident in what you wear unfortunately some people are just jealous of beauty."
Emotional Farewell for Weather Legend
This controversy emerges alongside significant changes at the BBC, as veteran weather presenter Carol Kirkwood delivered her final broadcast after nearly three decades on screen. The 63-year-old meteorologist struggled to contain her emotions during Wednesday's broadcast, fighting back tears as she bid farewell to viewers after 28 years of service.
Kirkwood announced her departure back in January with an emotional on-screen statement, explaining her desire to spend more time with her husband, police officer Steve Randall. During her final appearance, she was joined by her husband who presented her with flowers from both himself and the BBC team. The couple shared their plans for retirement, including extensive travel and the simple pleasure of watching weather forecasts rather than presenting them.
Tributes from Colleagues and Viewers
The broadcast featured heartfelt tributes from numerous BBC colleagues and celebrities, including Sue Barker, Vicky McClure, Paul Merton, Zoe Ball, Clare Balding, Chris Evans, and Sir Chris Hoy. Additional messages came from Charlie Stayt, Louise Minchin, Sian Williams, Susanna Reid, and Dan Walker, who described Kirkwood as "lovely, kind and caring." Presenters Sally Nugent and Jon Kay surprised Kirkwood with a special message from musician Bryan Adams, who thanked her for "all the great weather reports over the years."
Viewers also expressed their appreciation through numerous messages read during the broadcast. One wrote: "We're going to miss Carol so much, she rarely misses Shetland in the forecast and we always appreciate that." Another commented: "I hope Carol enjoys her last shift at the BBC, she has been a steady presence for us in a chaotic world." A third admirer noted: "Your smile has brightened up every forecast no matter what the weather BBC Breakfast won't be the same without you."
Reflecting on a Distinguished Career
During her emotional farewell, Kirkwood reflected on her remarkable career journey from production assistant to beloved weather presenter. She acknowledged: "After 28 years as a BBC weather presenter, tracking storms, chasing sunshine, and occasionally getting it completely wrong, I'm saying goodbye." The presenter expressed gratitude to viewers, stating: "You've been the constant in all of this, and I've never taken that for granted. I'm really going to miss you... I owe you all so much."
Kirkwood's career highlights included memorable broadcasts from major events like Wimbledon, the Chelsea Flower Show, Royal Ascot, and the Tower of London poppy display. Her cheerful personality earned her widespread admiration, leading to appearances on Strictly Come Dancing in 2015 where she reached week eight with professional partner Pasha Kovalev.
Personal Transformation and New Beginnings
The weather presenter spoke candidly about personal challenges, including her divorce from property developer Jimmy Kirkwood in 2008 after nearly two decades of marriage. She revealed this difficult period actually helped her "find herself" and become more adventurous, participating in activities like flying with the Red Arrows and skydiving with the Red Devils. Kirkwood found happiness again with her marriage to Steve Randall in December 2023, describing him as "tall, handsome, kind, gentle, strong, funny, charming" in an interview with House Beautiful magazine.
Jonathan Munro, interim chief executive at BBC News and Current Affairs, paid tribute to Kirkwood's exceptional contribution: "Carol's contribution to BBC News and BBC Weather has been exceptional. From major national moments to the everyday forecasts that are such an important part of our audiences' lives, she has set the gold standard for our accurate, valued journalism - always delivered with an appropriately sunny outlook."
As both presenters navigate significant career moments - Harper defiantly standing against online criticism while Kirkwood embarks on retirement - they demonstrate the diverse challenges and transitions facing broadcast professionals in today's media landscape.
