Self Esteem Shines in Teeth 'n' Smiles Revival, But Play Lacks Depth
Fifty years after its debut, David Hare's 1975 play Teeth 'n' Smiles returns to the stage at London's Duke of York's Theatre. This revival features Rebecca Lucy Taylor, known as Self Esteem, in the pivotal role of Maggie, a rock singer defiantly facing the twilight of her career. While Taylor's casting brings fresh energy and relevance, the production struggles to fully captivate beyond its musical performances.
A Nostalgic Look at Lost Idealism
Teeth 'n' Smiles originally captured the melancholic reflection of a generation mourning the faded counter-cultural dreams of 1969. The play revolves around endings: a rock band's final days, the crumbling relationship between frontwoman Maggie and songwriter Arthur, and an era's close in European music. Set against the backdrop of a Cambridge University ball, the story depicts the stark comedown from earlier glory, with characters refusing to fade away quietly.
Rebecca Lucy Taylor's Magnetic Performance
Rebecca Lucy Taylor proves inspired casting as Maggie, embodying the dangerously unpredictable rock star with authenticity. Her portrayal shines in the singing scenes, where she holds the audience with powerful vocals, eliminating the need for imitation that earlier actresses like Helen Mirren faced. Taylor's Maggie is catatonically drunk before performances yet miraculously delivers once the lights dim, adding a layer of raw realism to the role.
Energetic Music and Dazzling Visuals
The production excels in its musical elements, with songs by Nick and Tony Bicât, supplemented by new contributions from Taylor. Tracks like Close to Me and Last Orders are infectious and emotionally resonant, driving the narrative forward. Alex Mullins' costumes dazzle with a retro Jagger-inspired aesthetic, featuring fringed tops and leather trousers. Under Daniel Raggett's direction, the band performs with gig-like authenticity on Chloe Lamford's versatile set, enhanced by immersive sound design from Ben and Max Ringham.
Script and Emotional Shortcomings
Despite these strengths, the play's dialogue lacks substance, leaving the drama feeling centreless. The script meanders through themes like class commentary, youth's fleeting nature, and music's purpose—whether for profit or rebellion—without deep exploration. Emotional intensity and intellectual focus are notably absent, as if the narrative merely waits for the next musical number to inject life.
Maggie's character, while exuding a punk-like energy, suffers from inarticulate nihilistic rage that obscures other dimensions, such as her underdeveloped relationship with Arthur. Supporting characters, including the band members and manager Saraffian, often fall into clichéd roles, limiting their impact. Comparisons to other theatre productions about 70s bands highlight this revival's missed opportunities in relationship complexity.
Verdict: A Mixed Theatrical Experience
This revival of Teeth 'n' Smiles offers a compelling showcase for Rebecca Lucy Taylor's talents and a nostalgic trip through 1970s rock culture. However, audiences may find the drama itself lacking in depth and emotional resonance. Ultimately, it's a production where the music astounds, but the play struggles to fully dazzle.
