Sky Sports pundit Roy Keane has delivered a blunt dismissal of suggestions that interim Manchester United manager Michael Carrick should be appointed to the role on a permanent basis. The former United captain was speaking following United's impressive 3-2 victory over league leaders Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium.
Carrick's Impressive Interim Start
Michael Carrick took temporary charge at Old Trafford following the dismissal of Ruben Amorim, with his contract running until the conclusion of the current campaign. Club executives are actively searching for a permanent managerial appointment.
Carrick's tenure began spectacularly with a 2-0 derby victory over Pep Guardiola's Manchester City. He then masterminded a crucial away win against Mikel Arteta's Arsenal, demonstrating significant tactical acumen in his opening fixtures.
Keane's Praise for Immediate Impact
Roy Keane was quick to acknowledge the positive influence Carrick and his coaching staff have exerted on the United squad. Echoing post-match comments from player of the match Harry Maguire, Keane highlighted key factors behind the team's improved performances.
"Harry makes a good point," Keane stated. "They've got a lot of their players back now, it's a full group, they've got full weeks together and there's no other distractions. They can focus on the league form and they're producing."
He continued: "But, as we know you win one, two games for Man Utd, fantastic. Particularly to beat City, and come to Arsenal. I felt United would get a result today, I was thinking a draw but I felt United would turn up. They've got enough quality players and they've got momentum into their season and all of a sudden you're thinking it's a great chance for top four. If they play with that confidence and belief, you give the manager and the staff credit."
The Firm Rejection of Permanent Role
When pressed by fellow pundit Micah Richards on whether United should already consider making Carrick's position permanent given victories over the league's top two sides, Keane's response was unequivocal.
"The job? You're being silly now," Keane responded. "No, he's had two great performances but anybody can win two games. It's what he does until the end of the season. Even if they do get into fourth I still wouldn't be convinced he's the man for the job. Absolutely not. I still think they need a bigger and better manager."
Acknowledging Carrick's Opportunity
Despite his firm stance against a permanent appointment, Keane did recognise the significance of Carrick's current opportunity at the helm of one of football's biggest clubs.
"But, he's got the opportunity, what a chance it is for him and, do you know what, he's taking it so fair play to him," Keane concluded, offering measured praise while maintaining his position that United require a more established managerial figure for the long term.
The debate surrounding Manchester United's managerial future continues, with Carrick's interim success creating both optimism and caution among pundits and supporters alike.
