A Labour MP has launched a fierce attack on his own party's proposed devolution legislation, branding it a act of "blatant discrimination" against Cornwall that risks fuelling a surge in Cornish nationalism.
An 'Unholy Alliance' and Constitutional Clash
Perran Moon, the Labour MP for Camborne and Redruth, issued a stark warning that the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill could force an "unholy alliance" between Cornwall and Devon. He argued that any plan for a mayoral strategic authority spanning both counties fundamentally disrespects the constitutional position of Cornwall.
Mr Moon, who was elected in the 2024 general election, stressed that because of the national minority status officially granted to Cornwall by the UK government in 2014, the region "will never, Cornwall cannot ever, join a mayoral combined authority." This status, which places the Cornish on a similar footing to the Scots, Welsh, and Irish, grants them the right to preserve and develop their distinct culture and identity.
Severe Consequences and a Damaged Relationship
The MP cautioned that the consequences of the unamended bill would be felt for decades. He predicted it would severely damage trust between Cornwall and Westminster, baking in current "simmering resentment and disillusion."
"Regrettably it would not surprise me if the calls for full fifth national status for Cornwall will simply grow if this Bill passes unamended," Mr Moon stated, highlighting the potential for the legislation to backfire and strengthen separatist sentiments. He also questioned the practicality of the proposed joint authority, asking whether Devonian taxpayers would be willing to fund Cornish language lessons and bilingual road signs.
A Crossroads for Cornwall and Westminster
Having served on the Bill Committee, Mr Moon expressed his profound disappointment that the Labour party he loves had brought forward such a proposal. He revealed that despite several discussions with ministers about the risks, the government was proceeding with what he sees as an "ideological, governance template."
Urging a rethink, he said: "We stand at a crossroads. I urge ministers to be bold, be flexible, and empower our communities." He concluded with a firm declaration, stating that with a heavy heart, he will not be supporting the English Devolution Bill in its current state, as it would lock Cornwall out of the highest level of devolution based solely on its identity.
