Council Tax Slammed As Unfair And Regressive
Council Tax Slammed As Unfair And Regressive

Finance Secretary John Swinney is due to meet his Liberal Democrat counterpart Tavish Scott this evening to discuss replacing council tax with a local income tax. The meeting comes amid political uncertainty, as the SNP and LibDems hold differing views on whether the tax rate should be fixed or variable.

Under SNP plans, a fixed 3p tax on income would apply across all councils, while the LibDems want local variation. Even if a deal is reached, it would not command a majority in the Scottish Parliament, with Labour and the Tories opposed and the Greens favouring a property tax. Further complications include UK ministers threatening to withhold council tax benefit if the tax is scrapped.

Proponents argue that a local income tax is based on ability to pay and would see most people pay less, partly due to a £450m subsidy from the Scottish Government budget. Those on low fixed incomes, such as pensioners, and those with savings or stock income would benefit. However, critics point out that the £450m would come from other services, the fixed rate removes local accountability, and higher income tax could disincentivise employment. Additionally, removing the tax on property might inflate the housing market, and employers could face problems with variable rates.

The issue of council tax benefit remains contentious. If council tax is abolished, the UK Government has indicated it would withdraw the £400m benefit paid to Scotland. Some argue the benefit is no longer needed if the tax it compensates for is gone, while others see it as integral to council finance. The Scottish Government suggests using the Barnett Formula to continue the funding, but this remains uncertain.