Radical property tax reform could solve UK housing crisis, economist argues
Radical property tax reform could solve UK housing crisis, economist argues

Economist Josh Ryan-Collins has called for a 'big bang' overhaul of the UK's property tax system, arguing that incremental changes will not address the deep unfairness and inefficiency in the housing market. Writing for British Brief, the UCL professor says there is cross-party consensus that reform is needed, but warns that proposed cuts to stamp duty by the Conservatives and Reform UK would only fuel demand and push prices higher.

Ryan-Collins highlights stamp duty as a major culprit, describing it as a lump-sum tax that discourages people from moving home. With property transactions at near-record lows, he argues that reforming the tax could free up under-occupied homes, particularly among baby-boomers. However, he cautions that cutting property taxes typically increases demand for homeownership and inflates house prices, benefiting wealthier homeowners in London and the South East while doing little for first-time buyers.

On fairness, Ryan-Collins criticises council tax as a 'wealth tax on low- and middle-income earners'. He notes that bands have not been revalued since 1991, meaning a multimillion-pound mansion in Westminster can incur less tax than a modest home in the north of England. The system also favours homeowners over renters, with capital gains tax relief on primary residences costing £31.5bn in 2023-24 – equivalent to running the Home Office and Ministry of Justice combined.

Ryan-Collins proposes replacing stamp duty and reforming council tax with an annual proportional property tax (PPT) of around 0.5% on market value. He says this would suppress investment demand and free up housing stock for those who need it most. Research by the Fairer Share campaign suggests such a reform would benefit the majority of households, while also boosting productivity and growth by redirecting investment away from property and into business equity.