Artisanal Tinned Fish Revolution: From Pantry Staple to Premium Delicacy
The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?
Forget those multipack tins wrapped in coloured plastic that have long dominated British supermarket shelves. The world of tinned fish has undergone a remarkable transformation, evolving from mere convenience food to celebrated artisanal product. We're finally catching up with European traditions where conservas have been cherished for decades, representing not mass production but quality craftsmanship and premium ingredients.
The Artisanal Transformation of British Pantries
Like magpies drawn to shiny objects, British consumers have been captivated by beautifully designed tins that have flooded social media feeds, helping propel tinned fish back into shopping bags and onto plates. This isn't just about attractive packaging though – what's inside these cans represents a genuine elevation of quality. We're talking about premium fish preserved in various oils, ranging from Spanish anchovies to British-caught mackerel, each with distinct characteristics and culinary applications.
An environmental bonus accompanies this culinary shift: aluminium tins are almost infinitely recyclable, eliminating plastic waste and difficult-to-reuse packaging. From store-cupboard essentials to luxurious delicacies, here's our comprehensive guide to the best artisanal tinned fish available in the UK.
The Top 12 Tinned Fish Selections for 2026
1. Sea Sisters Smoked Rainbow Trout – Best Overall
Weight: 110g | Origin: UK | Price: £12 from Openfoodnetwork.org.uk
One of the biggest success stories in the tinned fish renaissance, Dorset-based Sea Sisters produces everything in small batches by hand using sustainably sourced UK-farmed fish. Their brightly coloured wrappers, inspired by Spanish tradition, have become increasingly popular with at least ten varieties now available.
The smoked rainbow trout (also available in chilli oil) has been smoked over oak wood and preserved in extra virgin olive oil. Delicate yet flavourful with good smokiness and subtle sweetness reminiscent of maple or honey, it's easy to understand why this product has earned a Great Taste Awards star. Perfect with scrambled eggs on toast, one tin generously serves two or can happily be shared between three to four people.
2. M&S Food Collection Cantabrian Anchovies – Best Budget Option
Weight: 30g (drained) | Origin: Spain | Price: £1.75 from Ocado.com
This well-priced tin represents excellent value for money, perfect for stocking up your pantry. Classic Spanish anchovies aged for six months and preserved in extra virgin olive oil, they offer good umami depth. Ideal for canapés at any gathering or for adding flavour complexity to pasta sauces, stews, and countless other dishes.
3. Rockfish Cantabrian Tuna in Olive Oil – Best Tinned Tuna
Weight: 115g | Origin: Caught in northern Spain, processed in Devon | Price: £6.95 from Therockfish.co.uk
From restaurateur Mitch Tonks comes this exceptional tinned tuna range. Using northern bonito tuna (rather than standard skipjack) caught by rod and line during a short fishing window in northern Spain, this represents a far more sustainable catch method. Each fish is hand-filleted and tinned in olive oil, resulting in delicate, soft-textured fish that's noticeably moister than average tinned tuna.
4. Ortiz Premium Cured Anchovies – Best Premium Tinned Anchovies
Weight: 78g (drained) | Origin: Spain | Price: £13.75 from Bbrindisa.com
The king of tinned seafood for many connoisseurs, Ortiz's primary-coloured tins are instantly recognisable on UK shelves. Inside are exceptionally large anchovies from Cantabria in northern Spain, salted for six to twelve months before being washed and hand-filleted. The result is long, meaty dark brown slivers with fantastic balanced umami flavour.
5. Waitrose No.1 Peppered Mackerel – Best Tinned Peppered Mackerel
Weight: 110g | Origin: Scotland | Price: £3 from Waitrose.com
This peppered mackerel in rapeseed oil delivers surprising excellence. Hand-prepared fillets smoked over beechwood achieve lovely flakiness in texture, while crushed black peppercorns provide a well-balanced flavour punch without overpowering. Perfect for quick salads with crunchy lettuce leaves and quality extra virgin olive oil.
6. Catalina Smoked Anchovies – Best Luxury Tinned Smoked Anchovies
Weight: 110g | Origin: Spain | Price: £19 from Josepizarro.com
Stocked in chef José Pizarro's online pantry shop, these large Cantabrian anchovies are aged for twelve months with a final month of smoking that elevates them to another level. Awarded three stars by the Great Taste Awards, they're perfect for savouring with favourite guests as canapés or gifting to anchovy enthusiasts.
7. Delicius Strait of Sicily Anchovy Fillets in Olive Oil – Best Tinned Sicilian Anchovies
Weight: 28g (drained) | Origin: Italy | Price: Available from specialist retailers
Offering variety from the predominantly Spanish selections, these anchovies come from the Strait of Sicily. Typically smaller than Cantabrian varieties but slightly chunkier than similarly priced options, Sicilian anchovies tend to be more tender, delicate, and sometimes saltier. Excellent for Mediterranean salads and pasta dishes.
8. Sainsbury's Taste The Difference Anchovy Fillets – Best Large Tin for Value
Weight: 74g (drained) | Origin: Spain | Price: £2 from Sainsburys.co.uk
This generously packed tin offers excellent value, containing Marine Stewardship Council-certified sustainable anchovies from the Northeast Atlantic. Preserved in good quality extra virgin olive oil, the longer, thinner fillets deliver delicious deep umami flavour with an appealing aftertaste, perfect for snacking on toast.
9. Los Peperetes Sardines in Olive Oil – Best Tinned Small Sardines
Weight: 120g | Origin: Spain | Price: £13 from Josepizarro.com
Hailing from Galicia in northwest Spain, these smaller sardines preserve excellent flavour through olive oil preservation. Still juicy and flavourful (though containing spines requiring careful removal), all fish from Los Peperetes is processed by hand using techniques passed through family generations.
10. La Narval Sardines Picantes – Best Tinned Sardines in Spicy Sauce
Weight: 120g | Origin: Spain | Price: £4 from Brindisa.com
From the Galician region of Ría de Arousa, La Narval offers sardines already tinned in picante (spicy tomato-based sauce), making them ideal for quick lunches. Caught using small boats and processed by hand, they have firm texture and great savoury flavour, perfect for topping tomato toast or adding to salads.
11. Rockfish Mackerel in Sunflower Oil – Best Tinned Mackerel in Sunflower Oil
Weight: 120g | Origin: Devon, UK | Price: £7 from Therockfish.co.uk
Defying expectations about sunflower oil preservation, Rockfish's British mackerel caught by Brixham boats delivers fresh-tasting, juicy fish with soft texture ideal for spreading on toast. Landed and processed in Devon, it represents excellent British seafood.
12. ABC+ Mackerel Fillets in Garlic Olive Oil – Best Tinned Mackerel Fillets for Pasta
Weight: 120g | Origin: Portugal | Price: £12 from Souschef.co.uk
Portuguese-caught mackerel fillets deboned by hand and tinned in garlic-infused oil with parsley and lemon create a creamy sauce perfect for speedy dinners. Part of the Jose Gourmet brand committed to fair fish prices and sustainable catching methods, ideal for pasta dishes, salads, fish cakes, or canapés.
What Truly Represents the Best Tinned Fish?
While numerous brands have elevated tinned fish beyond its pantry-staple reputation, Sea Sisters stands out as exceptional, with their smoked rainbow trout being a particular favourite. Incredibly flavourful with great texture and extra points for UK canning, it represents artisanal excellence.
For luxury occasions, Catalina smoked anchovies will impress guests as pre-dinner canapés and make excellent gifts. Meanwhile, Waitrose No 1 peppered mackerel transforms quick salads with minimal effort but maximum flavour.
How We Tested: Rigorous Evaluation Criteria
To separate genuine standouts from well-packaged mediocrity, we employed rigorous testing criteria:
- Flavour Assessment: Evaluating quality of flavour including gentle smokiness, balanced saltiness, umami richness, and olive oil quality used for preservation.
- Sourcing Scrutiny: Investigating fishing methods with preference for small boats and environmentally sensitive techniques like line fishing that minimise seabed damage, bycatch, and overfishing.
- Value Analysis: Considering that conservas represent artisanal products that should be priced accordingly, while including both luxury and everyday options.
Tinned fish has truly shaken off its humble reputation to emerge as a bona fide delicacy worthy of celebration and careful selection. Whether you're seeking everyday essentials or special occasion luxuries, this guide provides comprehensive insight into the best artisanal options available to British consumers.
