Veterinarian Sparks Debate Over Dog Breed Aggression Claims
Veterinarian Amir Anwary has ignited a fierce online debate after asserting that one specific dog breed exhibits greater aggression than pitbulls. The professional, who utilises social media platforms to educate pet owners, shared his controversial viewpoint in a recent TikTok video that has since garnered significant attention and mixed reactions from the public.
Controversial Breed Comparison Goes Viral
In his viral social media post, Anwary directly challenged common perceptions about canine aggression. "Everyone says that pitbulls are the most aggressive dog breed," he stated before revealing his surprising alternative: the Belgian Malinois. The video featured text overlay naming the breed while Anwary peered through a partially opened door, creating dramatic emphasis for his claim.
Why Belgian Malinois Require Special Consideration
The veterinarian elaborated on his position in a separate video, offering stern warnings to prospective dog owners. He described Belgian Malinois as fundamentally different from typical household pets, characterising them as "machines" rather than conventional companions. "They're not a normal dog, not a normal pet," Anwary emphasised, highlighting the breed's exceptional demands.
According to the veterinary professional, these dogs require extraordinary commitment from their owners. "This dog is not just an add-on to your life - this is your life," he explained. Anwary stressed that Belgian Malinois need substantial physical exercise and mental stimulation simply to maintain basic contentment, advising thorough research before considering ownership.
Social Media Reacts With Strong Opinions
The online response to Anwary's claims has been passionate and divided. One commenter offered particularly vivid descriptions, suggesting: "Aggressive is not the word I'd use to describe a Belgian Malinois - maybe psychotic, bats*** crazy, or downright insane. Anything along those lines."
Another user focused on the breed's intelligence as a potential concern, noting: "The problem with Malinois is that they're too smart. In the hands of the wrong owner, it could be an absolute disaster." This perspective highlights how canine intellect, when mismatched with inadequate training, might contribute to behavioural issues.
Practical experiences also informed the discussion, with a UPS delivery driver sharing: "As a UPS driver, there are two breeds I'm terrified of - Chihuahuas and Malinois." This real-world observation adds dimension to the theoretical debate about breed temperament.
Broader Perspectives on Canine Aggression
Beyond the specific breed comparison, several commenters offered wider insights about dog behaviour. One individual with extensive emergency room experience commented: "I've worked in the ER for over 30 years, and the vast majority of dog bites are not only from pitbulls." This observation suggests breed-specific aggression might be more complex than simple categorisations imply.
Meanwhile, some users defended both breeds mentioned in the discussion. A pitbull owner shared an amusing anecdote about their pet's temperamental behaviour, while another who owns both pitbulls and a Belgian Malinois described their Malinois as "just as cuddly" and compared the dog to Toothless from How to Train Your Dragon.
Essential Advice for Prospective Dog Owners
Regardless of the specific breed debate, Anwary offers crucial guidance for anyone considering dog ownership. He strongly recommends comprehensive research and direct interaction with breeds before making commitments. The veterinarian emphasises that proper training represents a non-negotiable investment, whether through formal classes, home-based instruction, or careful socialisation programmes.
This professional advice underscores that responsible pet ownership extends beyond breed selection to encompass ongoing education, appropriate environment preparation, and consistent behavioural guidance. The heated discussion about specific breeds ultimately highlights the broader importance of matching canine companions to suitable owners and lifestyles.
