For generations, pet owners have passionately debated one of life's great questions: do dogs genuinely love their owners more than cats, or is feline affection simply more subtle? Now, a leading animal expert has delivered a definitive verdict that might surprise both canine and feline enthusiasts.
The Science Behind Animal Affection
Animal behaviourist and author Lorna Winter, who serves as director of the puppy training app Zigzag, has weighed in on this age-old debate with scientific evidence. Her analysis reveals that both species form genuine bonds with their human companions, but express their attachment in fundamentally different ways.
"Dogs are pack animals by nature," Winter explains. "They've evolved alongside humans for thousands of years, developing what's essentially a cross-species friendship. Their displays of affection are obvious - wagging tails, excited greetings, and constant companionship."
Decoding Feline Behaviour
While cats might seem more aloof, Winter argues this doesn't indicate less affection. "Cats are more independent creatures who show their love differently," she notes. "When a cat chooses to sit on your lap or slow-blinks at you, that's their equivalent of a dog's enthusiastic welcome."
The expert reveals that cats demonstrate trust and affection through subtle behaviours many owners misinterpret:
- The slow blink: Often called a "cat kiss," this indicates comfort and trust
- Kneading: A comforting behaviour carried over from kittenhood
- Head-butting: Scent marking that signifies you're part of their family
- Purring: Not just contentment, but sometimes a self-soothing mechanism
The Bonding Difference
Winter's analysis suggests the key difference lies in how each species forms attachments. "Dogs see us as family members and protectors, while cats view us as equals - perhaps as larger, less graceful cats who provide food and shelter," she explains.
Research supports that both pets experience similar neurochemical responses when interacting with their owners. Both species release oxytocin - the "love hormone" - during positive interactions with humans, though dogs typically show higher spikes.
The Final Verdict
So which pet loves their owner more? According to Winter, "It's not about which species loves more, but how they express that love. Dogs are like enthusiastic friends who wear their hearts on their sleeves, while cats are the companions who show their affection through quiet, consistent presence."
The expert concludes that both pets form genuine, meaningful bonds with their human families. The perception that dogs are more loving stems from their more demonstrative nature, while cats express devotion in ways that require understanding their unique behavioural language.
Ultimately, the depth of the bond may depend more on individual personality, upbringing, and the quality of care provided than on whether the pet is feline or canine.
