Fashion designer Stella McCartney and her husband Alasdhair Willis have launched a scathing attack on a local ecologist who has raised objections to their proposed £5million seafront mansion in the Scottish Highlands. The couple, who are seeking to build at Commando Rock in Glenuig on the Moidart peninsula, have faced multiple objections lodged with Highland Council regarding their planning application.
Ecologist's Concerns Over Protected Otters
The controversy centres around an otter survey that identified holts of the protected species near the proposed development site. Local ecologist Dr Leon Durbin has taken issue with the plans, proposing a 650-foot exclusion zone to safeguard the animals and their habitat. This recommendation forms part of his formal objection to the planning application, which is submitted in Mr Willis's name.
Couple's Strong Response to Criticism
Ms McCartney, 54, and her husband have now responded forcefully to Dr Durbin's intervention, describing it as 'particularly galling' to be criticised by him. A spokesman for the couple issued a statement highlighting a previous incident involving the ecologist: 'A fire caused by Dr Durbin in 2021 caused immense environmental damage, scorching almost 30 acres of land. Dr Durbin may want to reflect on his comments as it is clearly ironic that a man responsible for such damage is now so exercised about our plans.'
Background to the Environmental Incident
The referenced blaze occurred in Lochailort and resulted from a garden fire that got out of control. Following the incident, Dr Durbin described it as his 'greatest regret', acknowledging the significant environmental impact. The couple's representatives have brought this past event into the current planning dispute, suggesting it undermines the ecologist's credibility regarding environmental concerns.
Ecologist Stands By His Objections
Despite the personal criticism, Dr Durbin has maintained his position regarding the development. He stated: 'I believe my objection responses to this development are correct and with my specific knowledge on otters I felt duty bound to comment, even at the personal cost of this old news being dredged up.' His comments indicate he anticipated that his past environmental incident might be raised during the planning process but felt compelled to voice his professional concerns regardless.
Planning Application Details and Local Reaction
The proposed £5million mansion represents a significant development in the remote Moidart peninsula area, which is known for its natural beauty and wildlife. The planning application has attracted attention not only from environmental professionals but also from local residents and conservation groups concerned about preserving the area's ecological balance. Highland Council will need to weigh the development benefits against environmental protections as they consider the application.
The dispute highlights the tensions that can arise between private development ambitions and environmental conservation efforts, particularly in sensitive coastal areas. With both parties presenting strong arguments, the planning decision is likely to be closely watched by both development and conservation interests across the Highlands region.
