Silent Witness Fans Divided as Show Relocates from London to Birmingham
The return of the BBC crime drama Silent Witness for its 29th series has sparked a heated debate among viewers, following a major change in the show's location. The series, which follows forensic pathology experts investigating gruesome crimes, has moved its setting from London to Birmingham, with characters like Dr Nikki Alexander (played by Emilia Fox) and Jack Hodgson (David Caves) now operating from a new base.
Fan Backlash Over the Move
Many long-time fans have expressed disappointment, claiming the relocation has ruined the show. On social media platform X, formerly Twitter, one viewer criticised the decision, comparing it to the move of Waterloo Road to Scotland and stating, "Moving this show to Birmingham was a BIG mistake." Another post argued that the show needs London, suggesting it should at least pretend to be set there, as the new setting feels "AWFUL" and has caused the series to lose its way.
Fans have also lamented the loss of the Lyell Centre, the team's old headquarters in London. One viewer posted a string of sobbing emojis while expressing nostalgia for the Lyell, and another questioned why the move was necessary, calling it a decision that "totally ruined the show." Some have even joked that the new Birmingham setting has confused the series with Peaky Blinders, highlighting a perceived shift in tone.
Criticism of the New Set Design
Beyond the location change, viewers have raised concerns about the new set design at the Bowman Centre in Birmingham. On Reddit, one fan noted that after two episodes, the set feels "so dark and moody" compared to the brighter Lyell Centre, with glass cases in the mortuary reminiscent of a museum. They suggested that making the set brighter could improve the viewing experience. Another comment described the new setting as "unrealistically, boringly dark," indicating that the aesthetic changes have not been well-received by all.
Positive Reactions to the Fresh Start
Despite the backlash, some viewers have embraced the relocation as a refreshing update. One fan praised the Bowman Centre and the shots of Birmingham, saying, "Love the Bowman Centre and the shots of Birmingham are superb! The show has hit the ground running in their new town." Another agreed, commenting that moving to Birmingham was a good move that brings "some freshness to the show." This split in opinion shows that while change can be divisive, it also has the potential to attract new audiences and reinvigorate long-running series.
As Silent Witness continues to air on BBC One, it remains to be seen whether fans will warm to the new setting or if the criticism will persist. The debate highlights the challenges of evolving a beloved TV series while maintaining its core appeal.
