Acclaimed Agatha Christie Adaptation Now Available on ITVX
A critically praised period drama that has captivated audiences with its sensational performances and faithful storytelling is currently streaming on ITVX. Why Didn't They Ask Evans?, the three-part mini-series based on Agatha Christie's 1934 novel, has achieved remarkable recognition since its original release in 2022.
Star-Studded Production with Perfect Audience Score
The series boasts an impressive 100 percent fan rating score on Rotten Tomatoes, a testament to its widespread appeal among period drama enthusiasts. Directed, written, and featuring actor Hugh Laurie in a supporting role, this adaptation represents a significant achievement in Christie screen adaptations.
Will Poulter delivers a compelling performance as the honest Bobby Jones, while Lucy Boynton shines as the adventurous and witty Lady Frances "Frankie" Derwent. The distinguished cast extends to include Emma Thompson and Jim Broadbent as Lord and Lady Marcham, creating an ensemble that elevates the material through their collective talent.
Faithful Adaptation with Light-Hearted Thriller Tone
Unlike many contemporary Christie adaptations that have taken darker narrative turns, Hugh Laurie's interpretation intentionally embraces the "light-hearted thriller" tone that Agatha Christie originally envisioned for her novels. This approach has been widely celebrated by critics and audiences alike, who appreciate the production's cheerful and adventurous spirit.
Filmed across Surrey and Wales in 2021, the series meticulously recreates the 1930s setting through authentic period details including costumes and vehicles. The cinematography has received particular praise for its beautiful execution and atmospheric quality that transports viewers to another era.
Critical Reception and Audience Response
Audience reviews have been overwhelmingly positive, with viewers describing the series as:
- "Marvellous and exciting"
- "A wonderful whodunnit love story"
- "Exceptional"
- "Clever and fun with great chemistry between the main characters"
One enthusiastic viewer noted: "Mr Laurie has excelled in this wonderful whodunnit love story. Mr Poulter, but especially Miss Boynton are a joy to watch. And their interplay is lovely to see. Repeat viewing hasn't lessened the enjoyment."
Another commented: "It's not easy to pull off an Agatha Christie screen adaptation as we've seen twice now in Kenneth Branagh's Poirot, but Hugh Laurie manages to put it together wonderfully."
Balanced Perspective on the Adaptation
While the majority of responses have been overwhelmingly positive, some viewers have noted minor criticisms. A few found the plot occasionally challenging to follow, with one reviewer suggesting the finale could have been stronger. However, even these more measured responses typically acknowledge the excellent performances and beautiful cinematography that make the series worthwhile viewing.
This 2022 adaptation represents the fourth television version of Christie's novel, following previous adaptations in 1980, 2009, and 2013. However, this particular interpretation appears to have captured the public imagination most successfully, establishing itself as a fan favourite among Christie enthusiasts and period drama viewers alike.
The series is now available for streaming on ITVX, offering audiences the opportunity to experience this celebrated adaptation that has been described as thoroughly absorbing and exceptionally executed. For those seeking quality period drama with strong performances and faithful source material adaptation, this production represents an excellent viewing choice currently accessible through the popular streaming platform.
