Netflix subscribers are once again rallying behind one of the streaming giant's most critically adored shows, calling for the return of the psychological crime drama Mindhunter. Despite its short run of just 19 episodes across two series, the programme has cemented a formidable reputation as one of Netflix's finest offerings.
The Unfinished Case of Mindhunter
Set in the late 1970s, Mindhunter dramatises the groundbreaking work of FBI agents who pioneered the systematic study of serial killers, leading to the formation of the Bureau's Behavioral Science Unit. The story follows two fictional investigators, Holden Ford (Jonathan Groff) and Bill Tench (Holt McCallany), as they interview incarcerated murderers to understand the psychology behind their crimes.
The series, which draws from the autobiographical book by former FBI profiler John Douglas, features uncanny portrayals of notorious figures like Charles Manson and the BTK killer. Under the executive production of acclaimed filmmaker David Fincher, the show was lauded for its meticulous pacing, period detail, and unsettling atmosphere.
Will The Show Ever Return?
Since its last episode aired in 2019, hopes for a third series have dimmed, with Fincher himself indicating it was unlikely. However, a glimmer of hope emerged in 2025 when actor Holt McCallany revealed discussions about a potential revival. He reported that Fincher had mused about the possibility of concluding the story as three two-hour movies, contingent on the development of satisfactory scripts.
This news has fuelled the fervent desires of a dedicated fanbase, who continue to discover and champion the series on social media and review platforms.
A Legacy of Critical Acclaim
The show's quality is reflected in its near-perfect scores on review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, where the first series holds a 97% approval rating and the second an exceptional 99%. Fans on platforms like Reddit frequently label it "the best thing Netflix ever did", praising its casting, writing, and cinematography.
Critics echoed this sentiment; The Boston Globe highlighted its "seductively paced" scenes and "noir" tone, while Vanity Fair called it a "satisfying FBI mystery" testament to sharp directing.
For now, both long-time devotees and new viewers can stream the entire, albeit brief, saga of Mindhunter on Netflix, a compact masterpiece that continues to leave audiences wanting more.
