Netflix's Roommates: A Hidden Gem in College Comedy
In the early days of Adam Sandler's deal with Netflix, the output was often criticised as lacklustre, with films like The Ridiculous 6 and Sandy Wexler failing to impress. However, as Sandler's career evolved, so did the projects from his production company, Happy Madison. Recent successes include the animated adventure Leo, which offered genuine warmth, and the basketball drama Hustle, where Sandler's performance was widely praised. The 2023 coming-of-age comedy You Are So Not Invited to My Bat Mitzvah marked a turning point, showcasing a shift toward more nuanced teen stories without patronising its audience.
A Baffling Burial by Netflix
Despite this positive trajectory, Netflix has curiously chosen to keep Roommates from critics, a strategy typically reserved for films with quality concerns. This decision is particularly puzzling given the film's merits. In an era where streaming comedies often set a low bar, Roommates stands out as a film worth celebrating rather than hiding. The story, narrated by SNL's Sarah Sherman as a college dean, follows the friendship between Devon (Sadie Sandler) and Celeste (Chloe East) as it deteriorates during their freshman year as roommates.
Devon is portrayed as a relatable character who never quite found her place in high school, described as eager yet forgettable. In contrast, Celeste exudes an effortless, magnetic energy that draws others in. The script, penned by SNL writers Jimmy Fowlie and Ceara O'Sullivan, masterfully depicts the gradual collapse of their friendship through believable conflicts, such as unresolved Venmo requests and ambiguous social media posts, rather than over-the-top drama. This approach echoes the nuanced friendship breakdown seen in shows like Insecure, avoiding clear-cut villains and instead focusing on mutual misunderstandings.
Strengths and Shortcomings
Roommates excels in its detailed characterisation and the chemistry between its leads. Sadie Sandler brings natural charm to the role of the awkward Devon, while Chloe East is compelling as the enigmatic Celeste, showcasing her versatility after roles like in Heretic. Director Chandler Levack allows the performances to shine, though the direction occasionally lacks dynamism. Supporting roles, including Nick Kroll and Natasha Lyonne as grounded parents, add depth without resorting to clichés.
However, the film is not without flaws. Some plot elements, such as a hackneyed climax borrowed from other films, shift the narrative toward a more conventional hero-villain dynamic, detracting from the earlier subtlety. Additionally, moments like an exploding turkey scene with Carol Kane feel predictable. These missteps highlight a tension between the film's specific, relatable details and its broader, sillier aspects, reflecting a battle between Sandler's comedic instincts and his more refined production choices.
Why Roommates Deserves Attention
While Roommates may not reach the iconic status of teen classics like Clueless or Mean Girls, it offers a refreshing take on college life and friendship dynamics. In a saturated streaming market filled with underwhelming content, this film provides a sweet and salty treat that resonates with authenticity. Netflix's decision to bury it is a missed opportunity to highlight a project that could find a dedicated audience. Roommates is now available for streaming, and it's a comedy that deserves to be seen and discussed.
