An allegedly fabricated video game livestream from the evening a man is accused of murdering his pregnant girlfriend has been presented as evidence during his trial at Belfast Crown Court. The court viewed approximately one hour of footage purportedly showing Stephen McCullagh live broadcasting himself playing the popular video game Grand Theft Auto.
Details of the Alleged Livestream
During the broadcast, McCullagh was seen drinking alcohol, using profane language, and at one point repeatedly shouting at a character within the game to die. Prosecutors argue that this livestream was staged by McCullagh on the night of December 18, 2022, in an attempt to create an alibi and prove he had not left his residence.
The Tragic Incident
Police believe that Natalie McNally, aged 32, was killed at her home in Lurgan on that same evening. McCullagh, 36, from Woodland Gardens in Lisburn, has pleaded not guilty to murdering Miss McNally, who was 15 weeks pregnant with their son at the time of her death.
Prosecution's Argument
The prosecution contends that the Grand Theft Auto livestream was a deliberate and calculated effort by McCullagh to mislead authorities and establish a false narrative of his whereabouts. By broadcasting himself engaged in gaming activities, he aimed to demonstrate that he was at home and not involved in the tragic events unfolding elsewhere.
Court Proceedings and Evidence
The trial has focused heavily on the timing and authenticity of the livestream, with forensic experts and digital analysts expected to provide testimony regarding the footage's metadata and potential manipulations. The defense is likely to challenge the prosecution's interpretation, arguing that the livestream does not conclusively prove guilt or intent.
Broader Implications
This case highlights the increasing role of digital evidence in criminal trials, particularly involving social media and online platforms. The use of livestreams as alibis or deceptive tools raises complex questions about verification and the reliability of such content in legal contexts.
As the trial continues, further details are anticipated to emerge regarding the relationship between McCullagh and McNally, as well as additional evidence related to the night of the alleged murder. The outcome of this case could set precedents for how similar digital evidence is treated in future criminal proceedings across the United Kingdom.
