The defence attorney representing the man accused of causing the deaths of NHL star Johnny Gaudreau and his brother Matthew has asserted that newly reviewed toxicology results indicate his client was operating below the legal alcohol limit at the time of the incident. According to reports from the New York Post, the legal team for Sean Higgins, aged 45, is now pursuing a complete dismissal of all current charges based on this critical data analysis.
Background of the Tragic Incident
Former NHL player Johnny Gaudreau and his brother, Matthew, tragically lost their lives in August 2024 when they were struck by an SUV while cycling near their hometown in New Jersey. The collision occurred on the eve of their sister Katie's wedding, adding a layer of profound sorrow to the devastating event. Sean Higgins, the alleged driver of the vehicle, was subsequently arrested and charged in connection with the fatalities.
Testimony and Initial Allegations
During the initial stages of the investigation, state troopers Mark Allonardo and Adam Crespo provided testimony indicating that they detected the scent of alcohol on Higgins' breath following his arrest. Higgins himself reportedly stated to officers, 'I’ve been drinking beers, but I haven’t had one in like two hours,' which contributed to the suspicion of impairment at the scene.
Defence's New Argument Based on Toxicology
However, Higgins' defence lawyers have now presented a motion arguing that his blood alcohol concentration level was actually below the legal threshold when the collision with the Gaudreau brothers occurred. This claim marks a significant development in the case, challenging the basis of the charges and potentially altering the course of the legal proceedings.
Legal Proceedings and Recent Hearing
The motion was formally introduced during a virtual hearing held on Tuesday before Salem County Superior Court Judge Michael Silvanio. This hearing represented a major shift in the ongoing trial, as the defence seeks to leverage the toxicology data to exonerate Higgins. The outcome of this motion could have substantial implications for the case's trajectory and final resolution.
Additional Context and Evidence
Further details from the case include bodycam footage that captured the moment of Higgins' arrest in 2024, providing visual documentation of the events following the collision. As the legal process continues, more information is expected to emerge, with updates anticipated as the court reviews the defence's arguments and the prosecution's response.
The defence's reliance on the toxicology results underscores the importance of scientific evidence in legal disputes involving alleged impairment. If successful, this strategy could lead to a dismissal of charges, highlighting the complexities and nuances in cases of this nature. The Gaudreau family, along with the broader community, awaits further developments as the trial progresses.
