Criminologist Raises Four Key Questions in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Investigation
A criminologist has publicly identified several confusing elements in the ongoing investigation into the kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of American news anchor Savannah Guthrie. The case, which has captured national attention, involves the disappearance of the elderly woman from her home nearly two weeks ago, with her daughter Savannah making emotional public appeals for her safe return.
Timeline Discrepancies Raise Concerns
Criminologist David Wilson, appearing on ITV's This Morning, expressed confusion about the timeline of events. "It's confusing in trying to establish a timeline of events," Wilson explained. "Why haven't the family paid at the timeline seemingly requested?" He noted particular concern about Nancy's health, as she requires medication every 24 hours, and blood was found on her porch during the investigation.
Delayed Door Camera Footage Release
The FBI recently released door camera footage showing a masked individual at Nancy's home, but Wilson questioned the delay in obtaining and releasing this critical evidence. "I was completely mystified by how long it took to release that footage," he stated, rejecting the FBI's explanation about subscription issues causing the three-hour delay. He described the footage as a "real gamechanger" that reveals identifiable features like facial hair and a wrist tattoo.
Unclear Motive in Rare Stranger Kidnapping
Wilson highlighted the unusual nature of the crime, noting that kidnapping by strangers is incredibly rare, especially involving elderly victims rather than children. "What's been confusing for me is that law enforcement would try to establish a motive right from the get go," he said, explaining that kidnappings typically involve either instrumental motives (like financial gain) or expressive motives (seeking power and control).
Ransom Demands Without Proof of Life
The criminologist pointed out that ransom notes were sent to news outlets, including KOLD, with Savannah Guthrie confirming the family's willingness to pay. However, Wilson noted that the ransom deadline has passed twice without the typical requirement of proof of life. "They would want to see a photograph, or the abductee holding a newspaper with the date on it," he explained, emphasizing this standard investigative practice.
The case continues to develop as law enforcement works around the clock, with the family maintaining hope for Nancy's safe return despite the confusing elements identified by experts.
