A judge in Utah has ordered the public release of a key court transcript in the high-profile case of Tyler Robinson, the 22-year-old suspected of murdering conservative activist Charlie Kirk. The decision comes with minimal censorship, aiming to balance transparency with security concerns.
Redacted Transcript Set for Release
During a remote hearing on Monday 29 December 2025, State District Judge Tony Graf ruled that an 83-page transcript, along with its audio recording, must be made available to the public. The redacted transcript was scheduled for release by the end of that same Monday, with the audio expected to follow in approximately two weeks.
Judge Graf stated that only about one page of the lengthy document would be withheld from public view. Specifically, 246 words are to be redacted, primarily concerning sensitive security protocols related to the proceedings. "The court recognizes the substantial public interest in these proceedings and has approached its review with that interest firmly in mind," Judge Graf remarked, according to a video recording of the hearing.
Content and Context of the Hearing
The transcript in question originates from a hearing held on 24 October, which focused on Robinson's courtroom appearance. Arguments centred on whether the defendant should be permitted to wear civilian clothes and remain unshackled during future court dates. Judge Graf ultimately ruled that Robinson could wear his own clothing but must remain shackled for security reasons.
The brief 20-minute hearing on Monday was attended by legal teams, reporters, and Robinson himself. The suspect spoke only three words, confirming his presence by stating, "Yes, your honor," when addressed by the judge.
Broader Legal Disputes and Case Background
This ruling on transparency occurs amidst wider legal debates surrounding the case. Robinson's defence team has argued that allowing cameras in the courtroom could undermine his right to a fair trial. Conversely, media organisations and Kirk's widow have publicly advocated for the trial to be televised.
Judge Graf also denied a request to formally classify media representatives as a limited party to the case, noting that established procedures already exist for the press to receive information and contest the closure of hearings.
Tyler Robinson faces a charge of aggravated murder for the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk on 10 September at Utah Valley University. Kirk was shot in the neck while addressing a crowd under a tent on campus. Robinson, who is from southwestern Utah, surrendered to authorities on 12 September. Prosecutors allege that DNA evidence links him to a rifle found wrapped in a towel near the scene, a weapon his father believes was a gift to his son.
The state contends Robinson targeted Kirk for his political views. An indictment filed in September references family claims that Robinson had recently become "more political" and leaned left, showing increased support for LGBTQ+ rights. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty. Robinson has not yet entered a plea, and his next court appearance is scheduled for 16 January, with a tentative preliminary hearing set for May.
