In the ongoing quest for quality at bargain prices, we embarked on a delicious mission: to find the ultimate supermarket bagel. We pitted the own-brand offerings from discount giants Aldi, Asda, and Lidl against each other in a blind taste test that separated the doughy delights from the disappointing discs.
The Contenders & The Testing Ground
Our panel gathered a simple pack of plain bagels from each of the three retailers. The criteria were straightforward but crucial: texture, taste, value for money, and overall versatility. Would the cheapest option reign supreme, or would a slightly higher price tag deliver a noticeably better experience?
Aldi's Entry: The Surprise Performer
Aldi's bagels came out swinging. Our testers immediately noted their appealing, golden-brown colour and satisfyingly chewy texture that held up perfectly to toasting. "This has a proper bagel density," remarked one judge, "it doesn't feel like just bread in a circle." The flavour was pleasantly malty and yeasty, hitting all the right notes for a traditional bagel experience at a remarkably low price point.
Asda's Offering: The Consistent All-Rounder
Asda's bagels presented a softer, more uniform appearance. While some testers missed the classic, slightly crusty exterior, others praised their consistent quality and mild flavour that acted as a perfect canvas for both sweet and savoury toppings. They toasted evenly and maintained a good structure, making them a reliable, no-fuss choice for the weekly shop.
Lidl's Challenger: The Divisive Choice
Lidl's bagels sparked the most debate among our panel. Their paler colour and lighter texture divided opinion. Some found them too bready and lacking the characteristic chew, while others appreciated their softer bite and lighter feel. They were certainly enjoyable, but for purists seeking an authentic, New York-style bagel experience, they fell slightly short of the mark.
And The Winner Is...
After careful consideration and many crumbs, a champion emerged. Aldi's plain bagels took the top spot for delivering the most authentic texture and flavour that belied their budget-friendly price. They proved that you don't need to spend a fortune to get a quality bagel that stands up to generous lashings of cream cheese or makes a formidable bacon sandwich.
Asda secured a solid second place as a dependable and versatile option, while Lidl's offering, though pleasant, landed in third. The ultimate takeaway? For the best combination of traditional bagel qualities and unbelievable value, your next packet should come from Aldi.
