Napoli have delivered a firm message to Manchester United, effectively closing the door on any prospect of Scott McTominay making a sensational return to Old Trafford this month.
Manna's Clear Stance on Midfield Star
Sporting director Giovanni Manna addressed the club's January plans, leaving little room for doubt about the Scottish international's future. "We're waiting for [Frank] Anguissa, who is an important player, to come back. We've missed him a lot," Manna stated. He then directly addressed McTominay's situation: "McTominay is showing that he can be decisive in that role. The coach will make his evaluations."
This public endorsement from the Napoli chief appears designed to quash the growing speculation, which emerged last month, that United were considering a move to re-sign the player they sold for £30million in the summer of 2024.
McTominay's Meteoric Rise in Italy
Since his arrival in Naples, McTominay has transformed into one of European football's most influential midfielders. His pivotal role in Napoli's Serie A title-winning campaign last season was remarkable, netting 12 goals in 34 league games and earning the prestigious Serie A Most Valuable Player award.
Under manager Antonio Conte, the 29-year-old has been a near-ever-present figure. While his goal tally this term hasn't matched last season's heights, he has continued to deliver in crucial moments, scoring important goals against the likes of Inter Milan in the league and PSV Eindhoven in the Champions League.
Why a Manchester United Return Looks Impossible
Several significant barriers make a transfer back to Manchester United highly improbable in the current climate.
Firstly, Napoli's valuation and intent: The Italian champions have no desire to sell their star man. Reports suggest they would only consider offers in the region of £60 million, a figure that contradicts United's evolving transfer strategy under Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who has expressed reluctance to invest heavily in older players.
Secondly, United's uncertain direction: The recent departure of manager Ruben Amorim has left the club's recruitment priorities unclear for this January window. It is not certain which positions, if any, will be prioritised.
Finally, the player's own perspective: There is no guarantee McTominay would be open to a reunion. At Napoli, he enjoys a talismanic status and a defined, influential role in Conte's system—something he never consistently had during his seven years in United's first team, where he was often deployed out of position.
His success in Italy has led many to label his £30m sale as one of United's biggest recent transfer mistakes. For McTominay, Naples has provided the recognition and platform to reach his peak potential—a scenario that now seems firmly set to continue.
