In a stunning admission that will fuel the ongoing VAR debate, Premier League refereeing chief Howard Webb has confirmed Manchester United received a major let-off during their narrow escape against Brentford earlier this season.
The Controversial Moment That Could Have Changed Everything
During United's visit to the Gtech Community Stadium in October, the Red Devils found themselves trailing 1-0 deep into stoppage time before Scott McTominay's dramatic late double secured an unlikely victory. However, Webb's revelation suggests the outcome could have been dramatically different.
Speaking on Mic'd Up, Webb acknowledged that Brentford were wrongly denied a penalty when United's midfielder Christian Eriksen handled the ball inside his own area during the first half. The incident went unpunished by both on-field referee Simon Hooper and the VAR team.
Webb's Frank Assessment
"We should have recommended a review for the referee to go to the screen," Webb stated bluntly. "The on-field decision didn't see a handball, the VAR didn't see a clear and obvious situation. But we know since, and we knew at the time, this should have been intervened upon."
The PGMOL chief didn't mince words about the significance of the error, adding: "It would have led to a penalty for Brentford and, of course, we're always looking to have a positive impact on the game by correcting errors."
What This Means for United's Season
This admission puts United's dramatic comeback into stark perspective:
- Brentford could have taken a first-half lead from the spot
- United's tactical approach would have needed significant adjustment
- McTominay's heroics might never have been required
- Three precious Premier League points hung in the balance
The revelation comes at a sensitive time for Erik ten Hag's side, who have struggled for consistency throughout the campaign. Webb's honesty provides Brentford supporters with validation while raising further questions about VAR's implementation in crucial matches.
Broader Implications for Premier League Officiating
This isn't the first time Webb has addressed controversial decisions publicly, but his candid assessment of such a high-profile error demonstrates the PGMOL's commitment to transparency. However, it also highlights the ongoing challenges facing officials in England's top flight.
As the Premier League season reaches its climax, such admissions will only intensify scrutiny on match officials and the VAR process that continues to divide opinion among players, managers and supporters alike.
