Mystery surrounds the New York Giants' decision to rule a key player out of their final NFL game of the season, after he was seen enjoying a night out at Madison Square Garden just hours later.
From Sick Bay to Courtside Seats
Tight end Theo Johnson was officially listed as out for the Giants' Week 18 clash with the Dallas Cowboys due to an unspecified 'illness', having missed practice all week. However, the narrative took a bizarre turn on Friday night when Johnson was spotted smiling in courtside seats at the New York Knicks' game against the Atlanta Hawks.
He was seen waving to the jumbotron camera, appearing in good spirits, which immediately sparked a backlash from fans online. The situation escalated when Johnson posted a simple, defiant message on his Instagram: 'I am not sick.'
Conflicting Statements Fuel Speculation
In an attempt to clarify the situation, a Giants spokesperson told The Athletic on Saturday that Johnson 'has an infection, which is an illness, but not the flu or COVID, where being around other people is a risk'.
This explanation seemed to conflict with earlier comments from interim coach Mike Kafka, who told reporters on Thursday: 'So he's just still got a little bit of a sickness and just infection that we’re just working through.' The team has not disclosed the nature of the infection.
Fan Fury and Draft Implications
The sight of Johnson at the Knicks' 111-99 loss infuriated many supporters. One fan wrote on X: 'What? Can’t play on Sunday cause you’re sick but well enough to go to a sporting event???' Another added: 'That's an interesting way to treat an "illness".'
Some used the moment to critique his on-field performance this season, during which he made 45 receptions for 528 yards and scored five touchdowns in 15 appearances.
Paradoxically, Johnson's absence could benefit the Giants in the long term. The team remains in contention for the No. 1 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, but must lose to the Cowboys to have a chance of securing it. Currently, the Las Vegas Raiders hold the first pick with a 2-14 record.
