Manchester United's Summer Transfer Priorities Shift from Attack to Midfield
During the previous summer transfer window, Manchester United identified the revitalisation of their attacking line as a more pressing concern than strengthening the midfield. However, as the 2026 summer window approaches, the club's priorities have undergone a significant recalibration. The absence of European competition and a rejuvenated spell from Casemiro allowed United to manage adequately without additional midfield reinforcements last season. With Casemiro now departing and a top-four finish still within reach, securing a fresh starting midfielder has become essential. Furthermore, if United qualify for extra football next term, they might even require two new additions in this critical area.
Revisiting Last Summer's Prospects
Elliot Anderson, Carlos Baleba, Alex Scott, and Adam Wharton were all mentioned as potential signings for Manchester United last summer, yet no transfers materialised for any of the quartet due to various reasons. All four players have remained at their respective clubs, gaining another full season of Premier League experience under their belts. Over the past twelve months, their performances have either strengthened or weakened their cases for a move to Old Trafford, prompting a closer examination of their progress.
Elliot Anderson: The Standout Candidate
Elliot Anderson has demonstrated remarkable resilience amidst considerable upheaval at Nottingham Forest, who are now on their fourth permanent manager of the season—a Premier League record. Despite his team's struggles, Anderson has excelled, showcasing his ability to evade pressure, maintain positional awareness, and exhibit a strong work rate. These attributes make him an exceptionally rare find in modern football.
On the international stage, Anderson has cemented his status rapidly. After making his debut in September, he has retained his spot in every single squad selected by England manager Thomas Tuchel since. He has started five of six matches and appears firmly on track for the World Cup squad, building a compelling argument to start the opening fixture. At just 23 years old, Anderson has the potential to reach new heights if he departs the City Ground, earning a grade of 9/10 for his performances this season.
Carlos Baleba: A Season of Inconsistency
In contrast to Anderson's steady rise, Carlos Baleba has experienced a slump that has contributed to Brighton's underwhelming campaign. The Cameroon international ended last season impressively but has acknowledged failing to maintain those levels consistently this term. In a February interview with Sky Sports, Baleba revealed feeling "more relaxed" after a change of scenery at the Africa Cup of Nations helped him rediscover his rhythm.
At 22, Baleba still possesses considerable room for development. However, there has not been the same sense this season that he is performing at a standard justifying the nine-figure price tag touted last year. His grade for the season stands at 6/10, reflecting his inconsistent form.
Alex Scott: Impact Amidst Turmoil
Alex Scott has made a significant impact at Bournemouth despite considerable player turnover, including a decimated defence in the summer and Antoine Semenyo's departure to Manchester City in January. Scott has risen to the occasion with standout performances, though he admits consistency has occasionally eluded him. In February, he told BBC Radio Solent, "I think there were a few games where my levels dropped, but I'm back to my best. I'm definitely in the form of my life."
Scott earned his first England call-up in November but did not make his debut and missed out on Tuchel's squad for the March internationals. The resurgence of Kobbie Mainoo has sparked debate about whether Scott is the right fit for United, resulting in a grade of 7/10 for his season.
Adam Wharton: A Complementary Option
Adam Wharton has been a fixture in Crystal Palace's midfield and, like Mainoo, secured a place in Tuchel's latest England squad. The former Blackburn midfielder played his first international matches in nearly 18 months against Serbia and Albania in November, earning Tuchel's respect. Wharton is comfortable in possession and confident distributing passes in an inconsistent Palace side.
However, doubts remain about his ability to unlock more defensive teams—a skill that could be crucial at Old Trafford, even if it is not his primary function at Selhurst Park. Whether Wharton represents the right choice may depend on United's other midfield business, particularly with speculation intensifying around a potential Bruno Guimaraes transfer. Wharton's attributes could complement Guimaraes, though additional sales may be necessary to fund a double swoop. His grade for the season is 7.5/10.
Conclusion: A Clear Top Choice Emerges
As Manchester United shift their transfer focus from attack to midfield, Elliot Anderson has emerged as the clear top choice among the four prospects reviewed. His consistent performances, international pedigree, and potential for growth set him apart from Carlos Baleba, Alex Scott, and Adam Wharton. With the summer window approaching, United's recruitment strategy will be pivotal in addressing their midfield needs and building a squad capable of competing at the highest level.
