As another dramatic Premier League season concludes at Old Trafford, we deliver our definitive verdict on every Manchester United player's campaign. From unexpected heroes to established stars who failed to deliver, here's our comprehensive assessment of the Red Devils' squad.
Goalkeepers: Mixed Fortunes Between the Posts
André Onana (7/10) - After a nightmare start following his high-profile transfer, the Cameroonian goalkeeper dramatically turned his fortunes around. Despite early errors, he finished as one of United's most consistent performers, pulling off spectacular saves that rescued crucial points.
Altay Bayındır (5/10) - Limited opportunities meant the Turkish international couldn't properly showcase his abilities. His few appearances showed promise but left questions unanswered about his long-term future at the club.
Defensive Woes: A Season of Injury Crises
Diogo Dalot (7/10) - Emerged as United's most reliable full-back, demonstrating impressive versatility on both flanks. His fitness and consistent performances made him one of Erik ten Hag's most trusted defenders.
Harry Maguire (6/10) - The England international staged a remarkable comeback after nearly leaving last summer. While not always convincing, he showed tremendous character to fight his way back into contention.
Lisandro Martínez (6/10) - Persistent injury problems severely limited the Argentine's impact. When fit, he reminded everyone why he's so crucial to United's defensive structure, but availability remains a major concern.
Midfield Maestros and Misfires
Kobbie Mainoo (8/10) - The undisputed breakthrough star of United's season. The 19-year-old displayed maturity beyond his years, combining technical excellence with tactical intelligence that belied his youth.
Bruno Fernandes (7/10) - Another season of remarkable numbers and relentless work ethic from the captain. However, questions remain about his leadership during difficult periods, despite his undeniable quality.
Mason Mount (4/10) - A desperately disappointing debut campaign plagued by injuries. The former Chelsea man failed to justify his substantial transfer fee and wages, offering little when actually fit to play.
Attacking Frustrations
Alejandro Garnacho (7/10) - The young Argentine provided moments of pure magic, including that spectacular overhead kick against Everton. His inconsistency remains frustrating, but the raw talent is undeniable.
Rasmus Højlund (6/10) - A tale of two halves for the Danish striker. A slow start in the Premier League contrasted with his Champions League heroics, before injuries disrupted his momentum just as he found his scoring touch.
Marcus Rashford (4/10) - A deeply concerning regression from last season's 30-goal hero. The England international looked shadows of his former self, with poor decision-making and body language frustrating fans throughout the campaign.
Season Verdict: Room for Improvement
Manchester United's 2023/24 campaign will be remembered as one of extreme contrasts. While several young players emerged as genuine first-team prospects, too many established stars failed to maintain consistent performance levels. The summer transfer window presents a crucial opportunity for Erik ten Hag to reshape his squad and address the obvious weaknesses exposed throughout a challenging season.
