Roy Keane has delivered a blunt assessment of Michael Carrick's interim tenure at Manchester United, firmly stating that the club should not appoint him as permanent head coach even if he achieves a top-four finish this season.
Keane Unconvinced by Carrick's Credentials
Despite Carrick overseeing two impressive Premier League victories against title contenders Manchester City and Arsenal since taking temporary charge twelve days ago, Keane remains sceptical about his long-term suitability for the role. The former United captain dismissed suggestions that Carrick represents the best option to succeed Ruben Amorim on a permanent basis.
'You're Being Silly Now'
Speaking on Sky Sports, Keane responded to co-pundit Micah Richards' endorsement of Carrick by stating: 'You're being silly now. Two great performances but anyone can win two games.' He elaborated further, asserting: 'Even if they do get into fourth, I still wouldn't be convinced he's the man for the job. Absolutely not. They need a bigger and better manager.'
Keane acknowledged Carrick's opportunity, noting: 'But he has got the opportunity and what a chance for him, and you know what, he's taking it.'
Concerns Over Appointment and Backroom Staff
Keane has previously expressed reservations about Carrick's interim appointment and the coaching staff he has assembled. Before the victory over Manchester City, Keane commented: '(I'm) concerned, concerned with the appointment and the staff that have come in, the manager. But I think I would be like that with most people at this stage of the season.'
He referenced Carrick's previous managerial experience at Middlesbrough, where he failed to achieve promotion, stating: 'Looking at the group of players they have, it's going to be a big ask. You look at Michael Carrick, whatever his remit was at Middlesbrough it was probably to get promoted, he didn't do that. He failed there, but it doesn't mean to say he's a bad manager. It was a difficult job.'
Questioning United's Standards
Keane questioned whether the current setup meets Manchester United's historical standards, saying: 'To get this opportunity, obviously it's great for him but I look at the staff he's brought in. We sit and talk about Manchester United every week being the best of the best, and at this moment in time I don't see that. But even with the appointment and the staff, it doesn't mean they can't get results.'
He concluded: 'It's a great opportunity for him and his staff but of course I'm concerned. I felt that about the previous manager.'
Carrick Focused on Results Amid Criticism
Carrick has publicly ignored Keane's criticisms, focusing instead on delivering positive results. His interim spell has been marked by a significant upturn in performances, with United displaying renewed energy and tactical discipline.
Players Praise Interim Manager's Impact
Manchester United captain Harry Maguire praised Carrick's influence after the victory at Arsenal, stating: 'Michael [Carrick] has come in, and he's been brilliant with us. He's brought fresh energy, and the group has really galvanised. Obviously, two tough games [City and Arsenal], everyone probably thought we would come away from them with not many points, but we won both of them.'
Keane acknowledged the improved performances under Carrick, particularly noting the freedom and confidence displayed by the team. He said of the Arsenal win: 'They played with more freedom and came to win the game. To get that momentum and to score a brilliant goal like that off the bench, it shows a good attitude and mindset. They will be growing in confidence. They are playing with a lot more freedom. There is a full group, there are no more distractions and can focus on league form. They are producing.'
Despite these positive signs, Keane's fundamental position remains unchanged: Manchester United require a more established and proven manager to lead them forward in the long term, regardless of Carrick's immediate success.
