Manchester United icon Roy Keane has launched a blistering attack on defender Luke Shaw, dismissing the England international's post-match explanations as "rubbish" following United's disappointing goalless draw with Southampton.
The fiery pundit did not hold back in his analysis during his appearance on Sky Sports, taking particular issue with Shaw's comments about the team's mentality and application at Old Trafford.
Keane's Furious Response to Shaw Comments
Keane's trademark intensity was on full display as he responded to Shaw's assessment of the match. "I heard him say after the game about mentality and attitude - I think that's rubbish," Keane stated emphatically. "That's easy to say, mentality and attitude. What does that even mean?"
The former United captain, known for his no-nonsense approach during his playing days, expressed frustration with what he perceives as empty platitudes from modern players. His criticism highlights the growing concerns about United's inconsistent performances despite their recent Carabao Cup victory.
Defensive Concerns Despite Clean Sheet
While United managed to keep a clean sheet against Southampton, Keane pointed out significant defensive vulnerabilities that nearly cost the team. Southampton created numerous scoring opportunities, with midfielder Trevoh Chalobah coming close to breaking the deadlock on multiple occasions.
Keane emphasised that the result papered over concerning cracks in United's defensive structure. "They got away with it today, but better teams will punish those mistakes," he warned, suggesting that United's top-four ambitions could be jeopardised by such performances.
Historical Context of Keane's Criticism
This isn't the first time Keane has singled out Shaw for criticism. The Irishman has consistently demanded higher standards from the United squad, particularly from senior players like Shaw who have been at the club for multiple seasons.
Keane's comments reflect his longstanding belief that United players should embrace accountability rather than offering generic explanations for subpar performances. His uncompromising standards echo the mentality that defined United's most successful eras under Sir Alex Ferguson.
Implications for United's Season
The draw with Southampton represents another setback in United's push for Champions League qualification. As the race for the top four intensifies, Keane's criticism underscores the pressure on manager Erik ten Hag to address both tactical and mental aspects of his team's game.
With crucial fixtures approaching, United must quickly address these concerns to secure their place among Europe's elite next season. Keane's comments serve as a stark reminder that at a club of United's stature, results alone are never enough - performances and attitude must meet the highest standards.
