Police Watchdog Investigates GMP Over Andrew Malkinson Wrongful Jailing
Police Watchdog Investigates GMP Over Andrew Malkinson Wrongful Jailing

The police watchdog is investigating how Greater Manchester Police (GMP) handled the case of Andrew Malkinson, who was wrongly jailed for 17 years for a rape he did not commit. The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) will examine why GMP rejected complaints from Mr Malkinson's legal team, destroyed evidence, and failed to disclose that key witnesses were criminals.

Mr Malkinson was cleared by the Court of Appeal in July of the 2003 rape of a woman near Bolton. He had been convicted in 2004 solely on contested eyewitness evidence. His lawyers proved that DNA evidence linked another identifiable man to the attack. The Court of Appeal also ruled that the jury should have been told that two key witnesses were serial petty criminals with convictions for dishonesty.

During his legal fight, Mr Malkinson and his lawyers complained that GMP withheld information about these witnesses and destroyed the victim's clothing. The DNA profile of the prime suspect was recovered from the victim's vest top, but that item no longer exists. The IOPC said GMP did not handle the complaints 'in a reasonable and proportionate manner' and that its review highlighted 'significant issues'.

IOPC director of operations Amanda Rowe said: 'Given our concerns over GMP's handling of the complaints - and the significant public interest in a case that led to a man spending 17 years in jail for a crime he didn't commit - our involvement will ensure there is thorough scrutiny of the actions of police involved.' Mr Malkinson said he never trusted GMP to investigate his complaints and called for the IOPC investigation to be led by someone who is not a former police officer.

The IOPC announcement adds to five major investigations or reviews into Mr Malkinson's ordeal. Justice Secretary Alex Chalk has announced an independent inquiry into GMP, the Crown Prosecution Service, and the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC). The CCRC is conducting its own internal review, and the Law Commission is consulting on wider changes to criminal appeals. GMP is still investigating the 2003 rape but has not decided whether to charge the man whose DNA was found.