Colin Montgomery of Edinburgh draws a parallel between football and politics, warning against the dangers of unrealistic expectations. In a letter responding to a Guardian article about Andy Burnham, Montgomery argues that while hope is not harmful, the inflated hopes that often accompany major events—whether a World Cup or a new prime minister—can lead to disappointment and anger.
Football's Lessons on Expectations
Montgomery, writing as a Scot, acknowledges the familiar sting of dashed hopes in football. Despite Scotland never advancing past a World Cup group stage, high expectations soared after a dramatic qualification win against Denmark at Hampden. Reality, however, quickly set in. For England, the problem is perennial: the belief that winning the tournament is a birthright, leading to crushing disappointment. Montgomery notes that this year might offer a release from that curse, but the outcome remains uncertain.
Political Parallels and Their Consequences
In politics, Montgomery argues, the same mindset is more damaging. He criticizes the absurdly high expectations placed on new leaders, such as those on the left compiling shopping lists for Andy Burnham. When every item on the agenda is not ticked off in record time, resentment and anger follow. This intransigence, devoid of realism and compromise, drives people to extreme positions. Montgomery calls for a new political ballgame, emphasizing that crossed fingers are insufficient; a fundamental change in approach is needed urgently.
