Scotland's Children's Commissioner Nicola Killean has warned that Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer's proposed ban on social media for under-16s could drive youngsters to 'darker places on the internet'. She expressed disappointment with the UK Government's stance, arguing that the evidence does not currently support a blanket ban as a means to improve child safety online.
Concerns Over Enforcement and Effectiveness
Ms Killean stated that a children's rights impact assessment found a social media ban for under-16s would not be 'proportionate, effective, or enforceable' in protecting children's rights. She highlighted that the announcement leaves many questions unanswered, particularly regarding how the ban will be implemented and what it will include.
The Commissioner emphasised that children need to feel safe reporting harmful content without fear of repercussions. She warned that a ban could push children to less regulated parts of the internet, making them less likely to speak out about harmful experiences.
Impact on Vulnerable Groups
Ms Killean noted that certain groups of children, including those in rural areas, those with family overseas, disabled children, and those who rely on online spaces for support, would be 'particularly affected' by the ban. She argued that the focus should be on making platforms safer for children rather than excluding them entirely.
Government's Position
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer defended the ban, stating it aims to give children their childhoods back and protect their mental health. He acknowledged that some children might try to circumvent the ban but insisted on prioritising children's safety and happiness. The restrictions are expected to be passed by Christmas and enforced by spring next year, holding technology firms liable for non-compliance.
Mixed Reactions
While the NSPCC praised the measures as a victory for child protection, Ms Killean urged the UK Government to engage directly with children and young people. She called for stronger regulation of platforms to prevent harm, focusing on addictive and exploitative features rather than banning children outright.
The Commissioner concluded that platforms must be redesigned to be suitable for children, rather than simply excluding them from social media.
