Sharan Dhaliwal, a freelance editor and writer, has strongly disputed ITV News political editor Robert Peston's characterization of Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood as "one of the outstanding politicians of this generation" and "admired across the political spectrum." Writing in a commentary piece, Dhaliwal expressed disbelief that Peston's comments were serious, especially amid reports that next Labour leader Andy Burnham plans to appoint Mahmood as Chancellor in his cabinet.
Mahmood's Qualifications Questioned
Dhaliwal argues that Mahmood has few quantifiable achievements and lacks an economic background, making her a puzzling choice for the Treasury. She contrasts this with Ed Miliband, whom she describes as an "actually popular choice" being overlooked. Mahmood emerged as the frontrunner for chancellor earlier this week, with senior Labour members telling the Guardian that a move to the Treasury seemed likely.
Public Discontent with Current Chancellor
A YouGov poll from June 2026 indicated that 54% of the general public thinks current Chancellor Rachel Reeves is doing a bad job. Reeves' performance has been marred by controversial policies including means-testing the Winter Fuel Payment, hiking inheritance tax, and angering farmers. Dhaliwal notes a desperation among the British public for change, but questions whether Mahmood's financial acumen is sufficient.
Mahmood's Right-Wing Policies
Dhaliwal criticizes Mahmood's "inhuman anti-immigration policies," including plans to seize migrant assets and deport at will, as well as her admiration for former Conservative Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. These positions, Dhaliwal argues, place Mahmood firmly in right-wing territory, contrary to the fresh Labour approach the public desires. In November 2025, over 20 Labour MPs publicly condemned Mahmood's immigration reforms.
Burnham's First Mistake?
If Burnham appoints Mahmood as chancellor, Dhaliwal warns he would be mirroring Keir Starmer's approach and making his first major mistake. Burnham's team has suggested they want someone at Number 11 who will "simply execute their will" and "be a cipher," which Dhaliwal says undermines Burnham's claims of building new politics. She concludes that Mahmood is neither outstanding nor admired, and that her appointment risks pushing Labour further to the far right.
