In a move defying critical consensus, the Kim Kardashian-led legal drama All's Fair has been officially renewed for a second season. Streaming giants Hulu and Disney+ confirmed the news on Monday, 24th November, ensuring the divisive series will return to screens.
A Tale of Critical Panning and Audience Adoration
The series, masterminded by television titan Ryan Murphy, premiered earlier this month to a barrage of negative reviews. It holds a notoriously low 3 percent score on Rotten Tomatoes, with many critics lambasting its quality. Despite this, the show achieved a significant commercial victory, becoming Hulu's most successful premiere for an original scripted series and rocketing to the top of the Disney+ charts in the UK.
The drama concludes its first season with a two-part finale on 9th December.
What is All's Fair About?
All's Fair centres on a group of fierce and brilliant female divorce lawyers who break away from the traditional, male-dominated legal industry to establish their own firm. The official synopsis describes them as "emotionally complicated" professionals navigating high-stakes breakups, scandalous secrets, and shifting allegiances within both the courtroom and their own ranks.
The show boasts an impressive ensemble cast including Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Glenn Close, and Sarah Paulson, alongside Kim Kardashian in a leading role.
Divided Viewer Reactions Fuel Renewal Debate
The renewal announcement has sparked intense debate online, perfectly reflecting the show's polarising nature. Many viewers have taken to social media to express their dismay, with a common criticism focusing on Kim Kardashian's performance.
One Reddit user commented on the stark contrast between Kardashian and her seasoned co-stars, stating, "It's almost like you can see them trying to force the tiniest bit of emotion or response from her that isn't completely wooden. And as a viewer, any time she's on screen is just absolutely painful to witness."
Another disappointed viewer confessed to abandoning the series after just three episodes, calling it "unwatchably bad" despite high hopes from the trailers.
However, the show has simultaneously cultivated a dedicated cult following. These defenders praise its campy tone and self-aware comedy, which is reflected in a much more respectable 66 percent audience score on Rotten Tomatoes.
One supporter on X countered the negativity, writing, "All the hate on all's fair is crazy!! Maybe I'm just getting older and I love to see women taking their power back... Besides the bad acting I like it!"
The decision by Hulu and Disney+ underscores a modern television trend where strong viewer engagement, even when divided, can sometimes outweigh critical disapproval, ensuring the battle in the courtroom and amongst viewers will continue for another season.
