The Great British Bake Off, once a respite from the cruelty of reality TV, is losing its feelgood factor, according to critics. Despite a strong lineup of contestants in 2019, including fan favourites Henry, Helena, and Michael, the show has been marred by impossible technical challenges, mean comments, and a controversial double-dumping.
The decision to have an extra baker to celebrate the show's 10th year backfired when producers threatened to drop two bakers in any given week, a twist more suited to Big Brother. The double-dumping came during a Roaring Twenties theme week, when both Michelle and Helena were eliminated, sparking outrage on Twitter as the biggest scandal since the Baked Alaska debacle of 2014.
Cruelty has been a recurring theme this series. A signature bake by Priya was judged 'horrible' due to the colour of its piping, not taste. The Maids of Honour technical challenge was deemed impossible, causing Paul Hollywood to 'jokingly' walk out. Prue Leith expressed disappointment, saying 'this is a baking competition, and both Henry and Rosie made dreadful cakes.' Such harsh feedback leaves contestants tearful and deflated, a departure from the show's traditionally positive tone.
Themes have also become bafflingly abstract, with dairy week confusing viewers as most bakes feature dairy, and upcoming festivals week leaving fans wondering if it means bonfires or Glastonbury. Critics suggest reverting to classic pie or chocolate weeks.
Thankfully, the bakers themselves provide a bright spot, showing palpable support for each other. Henry wore a spider brooch in solidarity with Helena, and they all held hands during final judging. This camaraderie is what Bake Off should be about, but the rest of the show seems to have forgotten.
