In a blistering critique that has resonated with many viewers, beloved television presenter Alan Titchmarsh has publicly condemned the BBC's coverage of King Charles III's Coronation. The renowned gardener and broadcaster lambasted the commentary as overly "woke" and "patronising," accusing the corporation of failing to capture the solemn dignity of the historic event at Westminster Abbey.
A Historic Moment Marred by Modern Commentary
Titchmarsh, a staunch monarchist, expressed his profound disappointment with the approach taken by the BBC's presenting team. He argued that the broadcasters seemed more intent on imposing a modern, social commentary on the ancient ceremony than on explaining its rich historical and religious significance to the millions watching at home.
"There was a tendency to be what I call 'woke'," Titchmarsh stated, "and to talk about the monarchy in a way that was almost apologetic." He felt the tone was misjudged for a national event that was meant to be a unifying celebration of British heritage and tradition.
Calling for a Return to Impartial Dignity
The heart of Titchmarsh's complaint centres on a perceived loss of the BBC's signature impartial and respectful tone. He recalled the revered commentary of past broadcasters like Richard Dimbleby, who covered Queen Elizabeth II's Coronation in 1953 with a sense of awe and gravitas that matched the occasion.
"I longed for more of a sense of occasion... a bit more dignity," he remarked, suggesting that the modern coverage lacked the weight and reverence the ceremony deserved. Instead of focusing on the symbolism and centuries-old traditions, Titchmarsh felt the commentary was filled with unnecessary and distracting chatter.
A Public Divided on the BBC's Approach
The critique has sparked a wider conversation about the role of a national broadcaster during major ceremonial events. While Ofcom received a number of complaints aligned with Titchmarsh's views, the BBC also received praise from other quarters for its accessible and inclusive approach to explaining the service.
This division highlights the delicate balance the BBC must strike: honouring tradition and providing a dignified broadcast while also making the event engaging and understandable for a contemporary, diverse audience. For Titchmarsh and his supporters, however, the balance was sorely missed on this landmark day.
The BBC, in response, has stated it is proud of its "extensive coverage" which aimed to make the Coronation accessible to the widest possible audience. The corporation noted that its coverage was amongst the most-watched programmes of the year.
