The BBC's highly anticipated Celebrity Traitors has found itself at the centre of a brewing storm even before its premiere, as two contestants face mounting criticism over their approach to Remembrance Day poppies.
Singer Charlotte Church and actress Ruth Codd have both become subjects of public scrutiny after reports emerged about their decisions regarding the symbolic red flower, traditionally worn in November to honour fallen soldiers.
The Heart of the Controversy
According to sources close to the production, Church opted not to wear a poppy during filming of the reality competition series, which concluded recording earlier this autumn. The Welsh singer, known for her vocal political views, has previously faced criticism for her stance on various social issues.
Meanwhile, Irish actress Ruth Codd, who gained recognition through her Netflix appearances, reportedly chose to wear a white poppy instead of the traditional red version. The white poppy, distributed by the Peace Pledge Union, symbolises remembrance for all victims of war alongside a commitment to peace.
Production Timeline Clashes with Remembrance Period
The timing of the Celebrity Traitors filming schedule has emerged as a crucial factor in the unfolding drama. Production wrapped before the traditional Remembrance period began, meaning contestants weren't formally expected to wear poppies during recording.
However, critics argue that as public figures participating in a major BBC production, both women should have demonstrated more sensitivity toward the symbolic importance of the poppy to many viewers.
BBC Faces Another Sensitivity Challenge
This controversy represents the latest in a series of sensitivity challenges for the national broadcaster. The BBC's editorial guidelines emphasise impartiality and sensitivity toward national events and symbols, though these primarily apply to news and current affairs programming rather than entertainment shows.
A BBC spokesperson addressed the situation, stating: "Celebrity Traitors was filmed before the Remembrance period. We respect all our contestants' personal choices regarding poppy wearing."
Public Reaction Divided
Reaction on social media has reflected the ongoing national debate about poppy wearing. Some commentators have defended the stars' right to personal choice, while others have expressed disappointment at what they perceive as disrespect toward military sacrifice.
One Twitter user commented: "The poppy represents millions who gave their lives for our freedom. Choosing not to wear it on national television shows a lack of respect."
Meanwhile, another supporter wrote: "Personal choice matters. Not wearing a poppy doesn't mean you don't remember the fallen."
As the premiere of Celebrity Traitors approaches, the BBC faces navigating this sensitive issue while maintaining the entertainment value that made the original series such a massive success.
