The trial of a teenager accused of trying to murder a teacher at Milford Haven School reached its closing stages on Friday as jurors heard final speeches from the prosecution and defence at Swansea Crown Court. History teacher Vicki Williams suffered injuries to her head, hands, and back during the incident on February 5 at the Pembrokeshire school.
Prosecution Case: Planned Murderous Attack
Chris Rees KC, prosecuting, told the jury that the defendant, who was 15 at the time, carried out a planned attack. He said the pupil took the largest knife from the kitchen because it was the weapon he thought would cause maximum damage. Rees argued that the teenager's account of bringing the knife to school to show off was a desperate lie. He stated that while the prosecution does not need to prove a motive, the evidence shows he did it. He highlighted the injuries to Mrs Williams's hands and her description of the defendant having a look of pure hatred.
Defence Argument: Lack of Motive and Planning
Matthew Roberts KC, defending, pointed out that there was no evidence of planning and described the lack of motive as a fundamental and striking feature of the case. He acknowledged that taking a knife to school was unwise but noted that the teenager would not be the first 15-year-old to do something unwise. The defence argued that the teenager became involved in a struggle for the knife because he thought handing it over would get him into trouble. Roberts invited the jury to assume nothing and evaluate everything with an open mind.
Judge's Summing Up and Next Steps
Judge Paul Thomas KC summed up the case, reviewing the prosecution and defence arguments, the cross-examinations of Mrs Williams and the defendant. He told the jury they would not begin deliberations until Monday morning. The teenager denies attempted murder, inflicting grievous bodily harm with intent, and unlawful wounding. The trial continues.
