For many train passengers, the piercing sound of a crying infant or a young child's tantrum represents an unwelcome disruption they would gladly avoid during their journey. Now, France's national rail operator SNCF has responded to this common complaint by introducing dedicated child-free carriages on selected services.
A New Class for Peace and Productivity
Since the beginning of January, travellers on certain high-speed TGV routes have been able to book the newly introduced 'Optimum Plus' class, which replaces the previous Business Première offering. Currently available on services connecting Paris and Lyon, this premium option promises passengers a 'quiet, dedicated space on board' specifically designed for those seeking 'a journey that's ideal for working or resting.'
The rail company has explicitly stated that children under 12 years old are not permitted in these carriages, targeting the service primarily toward business travellers and others desiring maximum comfort without youthful interruptions.
Controversial Policy Draws Official Criticism
SNCF explained their rationale, noting how the class is 'designed to meet the specific expectations of our business customers or those who want a special travel experience with personalised assistance and flexibility . . . for maximum comfort, children are not accepted.'
However, this strategic move has generated significant backlash from France's children's commissioner Sarah El-Haïry, who described the new child-free option as 'shocking.' She insisted that travelling with children should be 'a reality to be supported' rather than segregated away from premium services.
El-Haïry pushed back forcefully against the policy, adding: 'We can't say "look out, we're having fewer children, we've got demographic problems" and send out such blunt signals.'
Rail Operator Defends Inclusive Approach
In response to the criticism, SNCF described their trains overall as representing 'communal life open to all,' emphasising that children under 12 remain welcome to travel in any other class throughout their network. The child-free carriages represent just one option among many, rather than an exclusionary policy across their entire service.
Broader Travel Industry Trend Toward Adult-Only Spaces
This development reflects a wider trend across the travel industry, where various companies are implementing similar child-free initiatives. Notably, Oceania Cruises, an American luxury cruise line, has recently transitioned to offering voyages exclusively for adults.
The cruise company's policy change began on January 7, with bookings made on or after this date restricted to passengers over 18 years old. While existing reservations for children made before this deadline will be honoured, no new bookings for under-18s can now be made.
Oceania Cruises explained that this strategic shift aims to elevate 'the onboard ambience' and was implemented in direct response 'to the preferences of its guests.' The company conducted 'extensive research' among their 'loyal repeat' customers, discovering that people primarily booked their cruises for the 'serene atmosphere, sophisticated service and unhurried pace' they offered.
As both rail and cruise operators increasingly cater to travellers seeking undisturbed, adult-oriented environments, the debate continues about balancing commercial preferences with social inclusion, particularly regarding family travel and demographic concerns.
