Sydney's Celebrity Italian Restaurant Machiavelli Closes After 37 Years
A beloved Italian restaurant in Sydney's central business district, frequented by billionaires, media moguls, and politicians for decades, has unexpectedly closed its doors after reportedly accumulating debts of $1.4 million. Machiavelli Ristorante Italiano, an iconic dining establishment that opened in 1988, entered administration just before Christmas, casting serious doubt on its future.
Sudden Closure After Promised Reopening
In a surprising turn of events, the restaurant announced in mid-December that it would be taking a short seasonal break and reopening on Saturday, January 17. However, Machiavelli has remained completely closed since its final service on December 23, with no signs of revival. Diners have found themselves unable to make reservations through the restaurant's online system, and the establishment's telephone line has been disconnected entirely.
The owners have maintained silence regarding the situation, leaving customers, staff, and industry observers in the dark about what led to this abrupt closure. This silence comes just six months after the restaurant celebrated its 37th anniversary with considerable fanfare, making the sudden administration proceedings particularly shocking to its devoted clientele.
Devastated Patrons Mourn a Sydney Institution
Loyal customers have expressed profound sadness and disbelief at the restaurant's unexpected demise. One regular diner shared heartfelt sentiments, stating, This one hurts. I was genuinely saddened to learn that Machiavelli Ristorante has been placed into administration. A true Sydney institution, and for so many people, the place for classic Italian done properly.
Another patron reflected on the restaurant's significance, saying, Machiavelli remains one of my favourite venues in Sydney. The room, the food, the legacy - it all mattered. It still matters. I truly hope this isn't the end, but instead a pause... and that this iconic restaurant is saved and reborn for a new generation of diners who deserve to experience it. Some places are more than businesses. They're part of a city's soul.
The shockwaves have spread through Sydney's dining community, with many expressing their dismay publicly. One customer lamented, Nooooo! I had many phenomenal lunches here. No words! An incredible Sydney institution. Another added, The restaurant was still going strong with many reservations. Very sad, while a third simply stated, So sad.
Distinctive Atmosphere and Decor
Machiavelli was renowned not just for its cuisine but for its unique underground atmosphere and distinctive wall decorations. The restaurant's walls were adorned with portraits of celebrities, business leaders, and politicians, creating a conversation piece that divided opinion among diners.
One customer commented on this distinctive feature, noting, One of the best Italian restaurants in Sydney. However, don't really understand the decoration in the restaurant with all the photos hanging there, I think that was a bit weird. Others appreciated the ambiance it created, with one patron saying, I like the underground atmosphere in the middle of the city, with portraits of politicians adorning the walls... The food is top-notch, the service is spirited, and the wine selection is also good. Great for business lunches and dinners.
Another regular observed, The atmosphere is surrounded by famous celebrity portraits of businessmen and politicians. Lots of deals are made in this underground restaurant. Meanwhile, a different perspective noted, The restaurant has its walls covered in photos of politicians and celebrities, creating an oddly mismatched atmosphere for what is otherwise a high-end Italian dining experience.
Consistently Excellent Reviews and Legacy
Despite the recent financial troubles, Machiavelli maintained an outstanding reputation among diners, consistently earning impressive reviews. The restaurant boasted a stellar 4.5-star rating out of 5, with customers praising various aspects of their experience.
One enthusiastic review captured the sentiment of many: I can't believe I have never dined here before! Old school Italian at its best. Hidden away on Clarence Street, you walk in to friendly and attentive waitstaff, delicious nibbles to start and a gorgeous understated venue.
Another patron with particular expertise shared, This is the best Italian restaurant in Sydney city. Tastiest authentic food we have ever had and my husband is from Italy so he would know. The most amazing seafood risotto and ravioli. Service is impressive along with the atmosphere.
A long-time customer reflected on the restaurant's enduring quality: This is the original and the best Italian restaurant in Sydney's CBD. It's been my absolute favourite restaurant since I first came there in 1997. The food is always the same, big beautiful portions. Wine list is amazing as are the staff.
The closure of Machiavelli Ristorante Italiano represents more than just another business failure; it marks the potential end of a significant chapter in Sydney's culinary and social history. For 37 years, this establishment served as a gathering place for the city's elite while maintaining consistently high standards that earned it a place in the hearts of countless diners. Its future remains uncertain as administrators assess the situation, leaving many hoping for a revival of this iconic venue.
